Hold down Control (PC) or Command (Mac) key + mouseclick to select more than one option
Midtown West >
Posted by Anonymous on 07/17/2006
Great food, great atmosphere, great service, and a great price! A group of 6 of us walked in without reservations on a Friday night at 6:15pm. We were seated immediately, had a wonderful dinner, a courteous server, and a fabulous time. I would certainly recommend John's to anyone looking to have an enjoyable meal at an affordable price.
Posted by dcfooddorks on 07/10/2006
Great food for the money. Bruschetta pizza highly recommended. Calamari was decent. Pastas great as well, only need a larger variety of sauces for pastas only marinara and bolognese. House red wine, montepulciano was very palletable for $11 a half carafe. Wasn't too busy. Host that seated us was a prick but our waiter was exceptional.
Posted by erabin on 06/21/2006
The service may not be the absolute best but the good is outstanding and is well worth your money. The prices are relatively resaonble.
Posted by gala62 on 05/22/2006
This branch of John's used to be a gospel church and there is still stained glass windows and the most gorgeous ceiling. Oh yeah and great pizza! We didn't bother with anything else so can't tell you how the pastas or salads are. Ordered the Margherita with basil and pepperoni. We sat right next to one of the ovens which made this "foodie" very happy indeed - absolutely mesmerizing watching the guys make all those pies so quickly! Great pizza, fantastic atmosphere, waiter was nice enough, but didn't check back on us at all (minor flaw in my book for a pizza joint).
Posted by Mark Wig on 04/07/2006
Maybe not the best place to take a date out the first time (its in a huge church), but she'll enjoy it anyway for the experience and for the food. Food is filling (pasta's are the Ravoilis) and the wine washes it down well. Service is fine and prompt. Great value for the food.
Posted by eileenstal on 04/01/2006
Went here for a business dinner with several international associates and John's provided a great atmosphere. We ordered various salads, garlic bread and brushetta for appetizers. All were good, except I wouldnt get a Caesars salad again. I shared a pizza, and some others had pastas which they thought were good. Pizza was good, almost as good as the original John's on Bleeker. Desserts were just ok. Overall a nice experience and I would go here again, especially with out-of-towners or for lunch. Service was severely lacking at our table and I could also see that several tables around were frustrated also.
Posted by Sara on 03/29/2006
Decided to stop in here after reading a Frommer's review. Ordered pizza one afternoon, and it was wonderful! The service was pretty good, and the manager made sure everything was good. Enjoyed it so much, decided to return again, and the food and service was still good. Tried a pasta dish instead of pizza, and it was just as good. The restaurant is much larger than the typical Times Square area restaurant, so you don't feel like your table is in someone else's lap. Definately will return.