Hold down Control (PC) or Command (Mac) key + mouseclick to select more than one option
Upper East Side >
Posted by Burger Burgler on 12/22/2006
I've been comparing many a burger in NYC and beyond and this one falls short of the rep. I found it distractingly full of gristle and after boasting that they know how to cook a burger to order, my medium rare was closer to medium well (unacceptable, right? right.). Do that to my salmon and we're gonna have words!
Posted by The Hamburglar on 11/22/2006
Overhyped and overpriced. The burgers are good, but not worth the trouble. I will spare you the hassle of reading another poor review. The negative ones below are pretty dead on.
Posted by UES on 11/10/2006
People who simply say "greatest burger ever" either don't know any better or believe whatever they read in New York Magazine. The Burger is good, not amazing, and it is pretty small. If you want fries that'll cost you quite a bit extra and they will come in a dish so small you can count them at a glance. Even the beer comes in a small glass. Really overpriced and overhyped. Come on people, branch out!
Posted by Anonymous on 10/10/2006
I heard so much about how good the burgers here were that I had to try it. Well after the subpar service and having to wait forever for the food, I must say there is nothing to rave about. The burger was okay, I have had much better at numerous other places in the city with alot less headache.
Posted by Anonymous on 09/30/2006
This is the greatest burger joint ever. Everything is good from the chili, to the burgers, and even the cake.
Posted by Anonymous on 08/22/2006
Came here last night after hearing so much about their amazing burgers. We waited for about 15 minutes for a table, after being told it would be 40 -- pleasant surprise. Our food came out quickly, and was consumed quickly as well. I ordered a bacon cheeseburger, and LOVED it. The bacon was crispy, bun was buttery, and meat was juicy. It was the perfect, yet simple, burger. Fries were great too. An overall satisfying meal. Price was a little high -- but I think it's worth every penny.
Posted by Anonymous on 08/13/2006
I have heard jg melon has amazing burgers so I figured i would give it a try First of all they act like its the opening night of bungalow 8 or something. You have to wait and I felt like they acting as if I was honored to be eating at jg melon. I thought the burgers were just ok. Nothing great. Its also over priced.