Welcome to MenuPages - Please Select a city:
MenuPages
Now Serving: 10320 Menus for New York City Restaurants
Hold down Control (PC) or Command (Mac) key + mouseclick to select more than one option
Hold down Control (PC) or Command (Mac) key + mouseclick to select more than one option
| Rating | Avg. Dinner Entrée |
|---|---|
| $$$$$ | Greater than $25 |
| $$$$ | $18.01 - $25 |
| $$$ | $12.01 - $18 |
| $$ | $7.01 - $12 |
| $ | Less than $7 |
Reviews from nymag.com
| Food |  |
Value |  |
|---|---|---|---|
| Service | |
Atmosphere |  |
Ticketing provided by
You will soon begin to receive the newsletters you selected.
To enjoy more benefits and personalization available on MenuPages.com, register now!
Posted by East Sider on 12/14/2011
Great American cuisine!
This is the place to go for classic seafood dishes. It is Upper East Side casual elegance at its best! Love the preppy boating decor.
Posted by Kathy on 11/12/2011
Has gone downhill
Used to be a reliable, if overpriced, neighborhood standby, but quality has gone down based on a recent visit. Ambiance is nice, were seated and served quickly, they got a drink order wrong but that happens. I ordered soup, after asking it was meatle was told yes. I was then served the wrong soup -- they brought me the vegetable w/pork soup special. Sent it back, got the bean one that I ordered (took 10-15 min), and that turned out to be the same vegetable soup w/some beans in it. Butter for bread was stale. Not worth the money.
Posted by Max on 08/13/2011
Forget it!
Atmosphere and service were OK but food is absolutely not fresh! You can't even eat the bread, we left after appetizer and canceled the rest. Maybe it was good before, but not anymore !
Posted by Anonymous on 03/31/2011
Not so great anymore
Have not been in a while and stopped in for cocktails and appetizers...$8.00 for a tiny dish of marinated olives? Are these people nuts?? Some restaurants put olives on the table simply for sitting down. I found this offensive and will not return...lots of Carnegie Hill overpayers anyway. So many better places close by too
Posted by Best Island Fan Ever!.... on 06/01/2010
Killer food & service
Island has one of the best dishes in the city.... Food usually arrives to the table in 15 minutes but some 20-30 moins. Due to crowdedness.... service overall is great.... great for small parties... specially BDay party... or friends night or day out... I would recommend this to anyone. So ENJOY!
Posted by aks on 04/12/2010
Superb neighborhood gastropub
I've lived two blocks from Island for 15 years now, and it's one of my favorites. The staff are charming, the ambience is relaxed and sophisticated, and the food is always first-rate. No, it's not cheap, but remember that Carnegie Hill is the City's most affluent per-capita neighborhood and it starts to make sense. Investment bank CEOs stop by here for a simple dinner with their families (I've seen them). The menu is varied, and always includes the burger, one of the best in the city IMHO. The waiters know me and my wife and greet us like long lost friends when we drop by. What more could you ask for?
Posted by neighborhood family on 03/21/2010
it's slipped big time
quick lunch. their famous popovers were cold and dryish. never brought butter. the pancakes were dry/leaden sent them back. cobb salad ok and chicken curry salad chicken was dry and tastelesss. maybe the McLaughlin's should eat here sometine. please fix it. it's been a main stay for our family since it opened.