Hold down Control (PC) or Command (Mac) key + mouseclick to select more than one option
Posted by Anonymous on 12/17/2011
As the only vegetarian in a burger loving family, I was wary when my mother suggested going to Island. Looking at the menu, I was disappointed to see so few meet free options. I ordered the grilled cheese expecting a mediocre one at best. To say the least, I was happily surprised when I took my first bite. By far the best grilled cheese I have ever had ~ neither too greasy nor too cheesy. Everyone seemed to love their food, burgers, shakes, and salads included. Although often crowded and sometimes noisy, I would recommend coming here to vegetarians and meat eaters alike.
Posted by DM on 10/23/2011
I got the stimulus plan: cheeseburger, chips, soda, for $10. The burger was awesome. Only complaint is that I ordered it medium and when I bit in to it it was pretty rare. It didn't bother me too much, but if you are particular about temperature, then make it clear to the guys on the phone.
Posted by Ira.b on 09/25/2011
They really do make a good burger. But my favorite is the churassco, which is their chicken sandwich. I've also had the chicken salad, which is a salad with chicken. The fries are ok, the baked potato is better. a welcome addition to the Upper West Side.