Hold down Control (PC) or Command (Mac) key + mouseclick to select more than one option
Village/ W Village >
Posted by Still Waiting on 09/01/2012
So I ordered 6 cookies at 11:45 pm on Friday. It's 3:30 and I'm still waiting. I get having busy nights but you cannot over extend yourself as a business so much that you will never be consistent. I'm afraid I won't be ordering from them again because there is one thing I can't stand, an excessive wait time.
Posted by Anonymous on 06/29/2011
Even though Levain is the gold standard in cookies on the UWS, I have to say Insomnia is MUCH better. I do not want a cookie that weighs a pound and makes me feel like I need to run a marathon afterwords. With Insomnia, I have the perfect treat and can live in cookie bliss. A cookie shouldnt cost 4-5 dollars; one dollar is more than enough to indulge in the moist, warm, and chewy yumminess that is Insomnia cookies!
Posted by Anonymous on 04/23/2011
I have never submitted a review before despite visiting this site over 100 times, but felt I had to given the inconsistency between the reviews and how incredible the 'Insomnia Cookies' are. I went in and ordered 3 cookies and after taking a bite of each I immediately turned around and went back to order 3 more. They are the best chocolate chip and PB CC cookies I have had in nyc, and I am always on the search for a delicious cookie. The price is totally right as well.
Posted by anonymous on 04/18/2011
Ordered 6 cookies and a glass of milk for a sick friend on Saturday night at 9 PM. Delivery still had not arrived at 11:30 PM, despite the estimated delivery time that had been provided when I placed the order of 30 - 45 minutes. When I called I was told that the delivery person had just left, and that I would not be charged due to the long wait. I found out the following day that the cookies arrived at 2 AM! Five hours later than the order I placed! And I have yet to be refunded. This absolutely terrible customer service is inexcusable, no matter how good the cookies are.
Posted by salad545 on 10/17/2010
The cookies arrive warm and are consistently delicious but my wait times have been 1.5 hours and 2.5 hours respectively. Like another reviewer said, whenever you call to inquire about your order they tell you, "We bake our cookies fresh, that's why you have to wait." Last I checked, cookies didn't need two hours to bake. By the way, I live 4 blocks from their outpost.
Posted by anonymous on 08/28/2010
I love this place, they have the best cookies I've ever had! The only problem is that they take a little while to deliver.
Posted by Anonymous on 10/24/2009
Best cookies ever! I always order them and they are fast and speedy!