MenuPages

What a disappointment. Our order was wrong; the food was cold; the entrees were very skimpy, and the prices have gone up. I've been coming here for years but won't be going back for a long time. I'll miss having it as a regular go-to.

The food is consistently mediocre. The service folks are very lovely but why did I wait 30 minutes for my entree. Then, in the middle of it, they say they are shifting servers so we get a new person that we never met. Then she offers us cheese on our pasta that we have half eaten. It feels neighborhood-y which is lovely but not worth the price or your time. It's NYC people! You have the world at your finger tips and Henry's doesn't cut it.

I haven't been to Henry's in a couple of years and decided to take my family (2 of them from out of town) to dinner. Because we were six, we called ahead to ensure that we would be properly situated. Once there and getting a table made to seat four comfortably, we were already disappointed. We had - a change of waiters, mediocore tasting food (although the shank was great), a staff mishap caused one of our party members to get her shoes wet no asking if we wanted coffee or dessert..very disappointing...it may be another two years efore I go back...

This is the type of place the UWS needs, so I really wanted it to be that good. I tried both brunch and dinner and see no reason to return. Very pleasant atmosphere, staff was fine, but the food -- well, there's no other way to say this -- is totally, entirely mediocre. A real shame. Hope it improves, so I can become a regular!

Absolutely the best food and service ever. I told my date that I wanted American food but not soul food or BBQ. He found the restaurant on line and made a reservation. When I arrived for our first date, I was impressed with his taste in restaurants. The waiter, Joe, was friendly and helped to take the attention off of us. This was a blind date through singlesnet.com. We had a fun time dissecting the menu. I ate the chicken with pine nuts and spinach. Excellent! He was still hungry after his Oyster po-boy sandwich so I shared some of my food with him. He enjoyed the beer selection while we perused the dessert options. I had the banana pudding and he the coconut creme pie. Both of which were simply delicious. After dinner we headed over to the bar to watch the end of the Rutgers basketball game. Thank you Henry for a great evening and hopefully the beginning of something new.

Was taken here for a business lunch and found the food wonderful, service terrific and atmosphere charming. We sat for 3 hours, as I noticed several other tables did, and never felt anyone was rushing us. Our waiter was excellent, with a great sense of humor. Loved it and am taking friends there for dinner tomorrow night.

My family (including 2 children under 5) went to Henry's for Brunch on New Years Day. We had a fabulous experience! The service was great. The food was amazing.