Welcome to MenuPages - Please Select a city:

Harlem Tavern

  • RatingAvg. Dinner Entrée
    $$$$$Greater than $25
    $$$$$18.01 - $25
    $$$$12.01 - $18
    $$$7.01 - $12
    $Less than $7
  • American (New), Gastropub, Cocktails
  • 2153 Frederick Douglass Blvd, New York NY10026 40.804723 -73.955382
  • (At 116th St)
  • click map to interact
  • (212) 866-4500
  • 0

User Ratings (Based on 15 reviews)

Food 2.7 Value 2.6
Service 2.3 Atmosphere 3.1

Other Restaurant Info

(212) 866-4500
Visa, AmEx, MC, Disc
Mon-Fri: 12pm-2am Sat-Sun: 11am-2am
Brunch, Dinner, Lunch
Accepts Credit Cards, Catering, Kid Friendly, Late Night, Live Music, Online Reservations, Outdoor Seating, Take Out

User Reviews

  • Harlem Tavern

    Posted by Krista on 07/30/2012

    Fair Weather Restaurant

    This is a tavern (not a lunch delivery spot), so do not expect the best salads or wine. Expect great beer and bar food, like fries and chicken wings (which are excellent by the way). Indoors it's a little too small for me so I only go when it's warm and sit outside on the patio. I've been here 3 times and have never had a problem. One of my favorite Harlem spots.

  • Harlem Tavern

    Posted by hardworker on 07/21/2012

    Not recommended

    While everyone's experience inside this place may be great, thier customer service sucks! They dont know how to talk to people! My co-workers and i work across the street from The Harlem Tavern and we attempted to place a huge order for lunch on a Saturday Afternoon. They had nothing that was on the menu. I got put on hold 4 times while trying to place the order and ended up being transferred to the manager because the order was "too big." Food from the brunch menu is supposed to come with a soda....i ordered the soda and was told by the manager "i dont have soda, but there's a deli across the street" despite his attitude I tried to continue to place the order (only for the sake of my co-workers b/c if it was just for me i would have hung up a long time ago!) I asked what was the total of the order and had to wait 5min for him to find a calculator.....and even still without giving me a total he insisted on me giving him a credit card number. i asked again for the total and he refused to give it to me. I must say unlike my "usual" self i was extremely calm with this man....but Harlem Tavern BLEW a order for over 20 ppl and will lose our buisness through word of mouth.

  • Harlem Tavern

    Posted by Anonymous on 02/25/2012

    Disappointing experience

    I went the the tavern for the first time on super bowl Sunday. The place was packed and surprisingly had a velvet rope outside with a one person waiting line. So pretentious!! Got in quickly and stood inside at the bar. Got shoved around by some patrons and was told by the waitress, when the shovers complained about my presence, that this was a common area to be shared by all. I was not so politely asked to leave the area! When I spoke to the owner about the situation I was brushed aside. I have lived in Harlem a long time and this has never happened to me. There is always a first but it's the last time I will set foot in the tavern on 116th street.

  • Harlem Tavern

    Posted by Catheine on 11/27/2011

    Wine Prices....

    12 dollars for a glass of house merlot on 116 St...Really? We had to stand inside by the bar. The place was packed and so noisy. But the outdoor area looked nice though.

  • Harlem Tavern

    Posted by thomas on 09/13/2011

    Nice place

    Very nice place, especially the large outdoor area. Had salmon for lunch with a glass of wine. It was very good. Nice service. Liked it very much. Will definitely go again.

  • Harlem Tavern

    Posted by Anonymous on 09/05/2011

    Mixed bag

    Labor Day late brunch, was able to sit outside under an umbrella without waiting thanks to a very accommodating host. Server had a pleasant attitude but spilled my drink on me while placing it on the table. Not an issue, accidents happen, but there was no acknowledgement or apology offered after I asked for a napkin. Ordered the burger medium rare which unfortunately was raw. Fries were good. Was surprised the draft beer selection was so small but a variety of bottles were also offered. The table beside me seemed to have issues with splitting the bill and getting change from the waiter. Frankly, I assumed the issue was theirs as they were students and concerned with cash to the penny and even discussed knowing they left a crappy tip. When I asked for my bill, $14.95 + tax = $16.30 total, I left a $20 and asked for change. The waiter returned with $3 and no coins. I left $2 knowing the extra .70 would suffice to make an 18% tip but would have gladly left $3 for 20% if I hadn't felt hustled. Small potatoes but important for good service. I might return for a drink and pleasant outdoor environment but food and service are another matter.

  • Harlem Tavern

    Posted by Maria on 09/02/2011

    Disappointed, But Hopeful

    Not that long of a wait, which was great for a Friday night. Salads looked great, so I ordered the Chopped Salad with chicken. The salad arrived and then I noticed I had no utensils! So, had to wait a while before I could get the waiter's attention to bring me utensils. The salad was a bit awkward (chicken was in big pieces, so you had to cut it) and the dressing was so disappointing, I could hardly taste it. I asked the waiter to bring me a side of ranch dressing. About 5 minutes later he arrived with blue cheese dressing. At that point, since my husband was already done eating his burger, I settled for the blue cheese dressing. Not sure why they have these pretty good salads, but dressing is not good! On a positive note, the sweet potato fries were amazing, the burgers were good, but the brioche bun didn't do it for my husband. All in all we had a good time, but just wish the service and quality of food could be a little bit better. I really hope the owners will take these comments to heart. We really need a quality restaurant in this neighborhood without having to drive all the way over to Dinosaur BBQ!

© 2015 GrubHub, Inc. All rights reserved.