Welcome to MenuPages - Please Select a city:

Gotham Pizza

  • RatingAvg. Dinner Entrée
    $$$$$Greater than $25
    $$$$$18.01 - $25
    $$$$12.01 - $18
    $$$7.01 - $12
    $Less than $7
  • Pizza
  • 1443 York Ave, New York NY10021 40.769746 -73.951615
  • (Btwn 76th & 77th St)
  • click map to interact
  • (646) 693-7046
  • 0

User Ratings (Based on 64 reviews)

Food 4.3 Value 3.8
Service 3.4 Atmosphere 3.0

Other Restaurant Info

(646) 693-7046
Place Order:
Order From Gotham Pizza for delivery & takeout
MC, Visa, AmEx, Disc, DC
Daily: 10:30am-12am
Accepts Credit Cards, Delivery, Lunch, Online Ordering, Take Out, Wheelchair Accessible
Min Delivery:

User Reviews

  • Gotham Pizza

    Posted by pizzageek on 11/21/2007

    Best pizza for blocks and blocks

    their crispy-crusted bad boys are the best in the neighborhood and they deliver it in a jiffy. No need to stock up on TP either; unlike the rest of the local pizza hooligans, this place won't leave you clutching your belly and praying for a quick death.

  • Gotham Pizza

    Posted by Mimi on 09/15/2007

    Best Pizza

    Best pizza I have had....liked it as much as "Joes" in the West Village which until now was unbeatable but too far away from upper Eastside. This place is a winner......crust is thin and crispy.

  • Gotham Pizza

    Posted by whoanessy on 09/13/2007


    Evrerytime I walk by the smell takes over my nostrils. I can't help but grab a slice, or two, or three. Nice people work there and the pizza tastes great!

  • Gotham Pizza

    Posted by Teddy on 09/10/2007

    Formerly Pinataile's Pizzeria

    FYI, this was formerly Pinataile's which is a small private operated chain. They do make delicious, thin, whole wheat crust pizza with decent quality ingredients. There are some Pinataile Pizza places (mostly on the UES). When I pass by Gotham/Pinataile, I find it hard to resist to grab a slice. Yum!

  • Gotham Pizza

    Posted by Anonymous on 09/07/2007

    Love this place.

    The Grandma Pie is the best slice I've found on the Upper East Side and their sauce is incredible.

  • Gotham Pizza

    Posted by Pomegranate's Pal on 09/03/2007

    Gotham is just "okay"

    Moved into the area recently and are trying out different restaurants. Although Totonno's comes highly recommended, we saw some complaints on Menupages, so we tried Gotham. The pizza arrived hot, relatively fast and very fresh. The delivery guy was nice and the value for food is pretty good. However, I was not impressed with the taste. While the crust was crispy (bet very thin), the sauce didn't have much flavor (needed grated cheese or garlic salt) and it was very greasy. This was misleading because the pizza was covered with green spices. My husband said "this was not what I expected." Nothing like an unhappy husband at dinner time. Oh well! We will not try them again.

  • Gotham Pizza

    Posted by tasty on 08/26/2007


    gotham pizza is unbelievably yummy. just moved here, probably hadn't had pizza in 3 years...and now eat from gotham at least 5 times a week. grandma's is delicious. must try this place!

© 2015 GrubHub, Inc. All rights reserved.