Hold down Control (PC) or Command (Mac) key + mouseclick to select more than one option
Upper East Side >
Posted by Sadie on 02/12/2008
Very good pizza, better then most places on the east side. Totanos soggy overpriced crummy pizza, little robbins lousy pizza, the Italian village (the worst) and all others on the east side. Very Very GOOD. TWO THUMBS WAY WAY UP.
Posted by Anonymous on 01/21/2008
I've been living in NY for over a year now and have been searching for the famous New York pizza everyone has been talking about. Until I tried this place, everything was doughy, greasy, and soggy. This place has just the right amount of cheese,the sauce is amazing, and the ultra-thin crust is perfectly crisped. Delivery was prompt and the price was great. Anyone else looking or that perfect slice, look no further. This is it!
Posted by Anonymous on 01/11/2008
This is a great place to get pizza. Every sunday the kids and I order from them the pizza just keeps getting better. We love the garlic knots as well. Gotham Pizza is a great addition to our lovely neighborly upper east side neighborhood.
Posted by Anonymous on 01/03/2008
I don't write reviews, but I love this pizza. Also, very good, articulate, and polite phone service when you call for delivery ...a rarity in this city. Get the Grandma pie...
Posted by Anonymous on 01/02/2008
When I first moved to the UES this was the first pizza place I went to. Gotham pizza is the best I have found!!!! I order from here at least once a week. The owners are great and super nice. I highly recommend this place!!!
Posted by Chikopoppi on 12/22/2007
I just got back from Gotham after trying four of their slices and I have to say, I am smiling :) I have to agree with other reviewer's comparison to Joe's. This place is clean and friendly with awesomely thin and crispy slices. They've been in business for 8 months so I guess it's still new to UES. If you are craving for thin NY style pizza, call here. IT ROCKS!! The owner was extremely nice as well. I am throwing away my other pizza take out menus because I am only going to order from here.
Posted by Slice of Heaven on 12/21/2007
Gotham is the BEST pizza around. Keeps you wanting more and more! The owners are very friendly as is the rest of the staff. You MUST try this place - you will not be disappointed. Get the Marghreta and the White... well - they are all a "slice of heaven".