Hold down Control (PC) or Command (Mac) key + mouseclick to select more than one option
Upper East Side >
Posted by Anonymous on 04/15/2009
They have the best pizza!! The margherita pizza is to die for! I was going down the street for pizza but no more...this place is melt in your mouth pizza. and the guys who work there are all very nice as well!
Posted by amanda on 04/03/2009
This is our favorite pizza and we order from here about once a week. Their plain cheese pizza is so delish... love the thin crust and cheese is just the perfect amount. Very little grease! Not the friendliest staff and delivery can sometimes take a while so we usually pickup. The grandma pizza and margherita are also very yummy. Can't beat the weekday lunch special for $5. 2 slices and a soda.
Posted by Matt J on 03/19/2009
Until recently we thought they were great. Then the pizza never came. We called - they said half an hour. Called after 45 minutes to see if they were okay. We were promised that the pizza was "seconds away"... after an hour we called to find out why it still wasn't here... when the phone wasn't pleasant we told him to keep the pie and ordered from Nicks.
Posted by anon on 03/10/2009
This is THE best pizza.Friends will travel from queens and brooklyn for a pizza party if I say I'm ordering here!Crust is amazing and every pie seems personally crafted, would love to know how they make their crust so perfect and different.One slice is NOT enough. And the staff is ALWAYS wonderful. ONLY negative thing is the slight irritation when using a credit card!
Posted by Anonymous on 02/08/2009
The grandma pie is by far one of the best in the city, and definitely the best on the UES. Very fresh ingredients, delicious sauce and perfect crust. Im addicted to it.
Posted by great pizza on 02/03/2009
last reviewer asked for garlic, and said there was too much. default you get garlic, if you ask for more you better be ready. i have always been 100% satisfied with gothams, glad they are here.
Posted by Aneel on 01/25/2009
After reading all the other reviews for pizza in the UES, we decided to try Gotham for delivery (that's why atmosphere received a 3.0). The pizza was lukewarm at best when it arrived. We ordered garlic with basil and mushrooms and they put so much garlic on it that we couldn't taste anything else. There were globs and globs of garlic. It was almost unedible. The crust was thin and crispy but there was almost no cheese either. We were not impressed. If you want good crust without much else this is the place to go.