Welcome to MenuPages - Please Select a city:

Gotham Pizza

  • RatingAvg. Dinner Entrée
    $$$$$Greater than $25
    $$$$$18.01 - $25
    $$$$12.01 - $18
    $$$7.01 - $12
    $Less than $7
  • Pizza
  • 1443 York Ave, New York NY10021 40.769746 -73.951615
  • (Btwn 76th & 77th St)
  • click map to interact
  • (646) 693-7046
  • 0

User Ratings (Based on 64 reviews)

Food 4.3 Value 3.8
Service 3.4 Atmosphere 3.0

Other Restaurant Info

(646) 693-7046
Place Order:
Order From Gotham Pizza for delivery & takeout
MC, Visa, AmEx, Disc, DC
Daily: 10:30am-12am
Accepts Credit Cards, Delivery, Lunch, Online Ordering, Take Out, Wheelchair Accessible
Min Delivery:

User Reviews

  • Gotham Pizza

    Posted by Anonymous on 02/10/2010

    slow slow slow and rude

    Pizza is delicious, service is terrible. Delivery takes an hour or more sometimes, they say it is on its way. and you keep waiting and waiting and waiting. Good luck!

  • Gotham Pizza

    Posted by the boss in manhattan on 01/24/2010

    best pizza in town

    My boys say it's the best, so that's all we order. And they deliver everytime, and timely. Compared to the rest, this is the only pizza in town.

  • Gotham Pizza

    Posted by anonymous on 01/02/2010

    Delicious Pizza

    Grandma pie is the absolute best...it is in the sauce which is fresh and authentic. A bit pricey but really worth it. Salads are mediocre as is regular pizza. It is all about the Grandma!

  • Gotham Pizza

    Posted by Anonymous on 11/11/2009

    Fantastic Pizza

    i have gone to gotham countless times. it is by far the best pizza in the area. definitely recommend it to everyone.

  • Gotham Pizza

    Posted by frequent customer on 11/07/2009

    delivery during peak hours problem

    this place has the best pizza on UES. I work and live in nearby. Problem is that they are getting very popular and they can't handle the volume and delivery when all of a sudden all of the hospitals/departments and locals order at once. Premere slice in house in a normal pizza joint setting (small), but expect delays if ordering delivery during peak hours.

  • Gotham Pizza

    Posted by JB on 11/01/2009

    Pizza never arrived!

    I can't opine on the quality of the pizza because it never arrived. We called once and were told "it's on the way", which is pretty funny since we live right down the street. I will never attempt to order from this place again nor frequent the establishment since fortunately we live in a city with more than one pizza place. There's just no excuse for any restaurant to pull these shenanigans.

  • Gotham Pizza

    Posted by UESWill on 10/31/2009

    Atrocious waits, delivery, reliability.

    File me under "former Gotham customer" who will never bring business back to their establishment. The delivery service is touch and go at best. The last time we ordered it took the 'first attempt' at the order an hour to arrive. I say first attempt because the pizza was ice cold (as food tends to get after an hour) and the salad was wrong. After sending back the salad we waited another 45 minutes before realizing that the salad wasn't ever going to arrive. We called and asked for the cost of the salad to be re-credited to our credit card, however no credit was applied. Fast forward, we decided to give them another shot. Upon taking our address (which they've delivered to before) they told us it was out side of their do-able range, and it would take anywhere in the window of 1-3 hours. That is not acceptable. I cannot with good conscience recommend this restaurant to anybody ordering delivery. In fact, I would encourage avoiding it at all costs.

© 2015 GrubHub, Inc. All rights reserved.