Hold down Control (PC) or Command (Mac) key + mouseclick to select more than one option
Murray Hill / Gramercy >
Posted by A&A on 03/23/2014
All I know is my wife & I order the old world pizza and it's amazing. I would not call a pizza place for gourmet dishes like the other reviewers. Go with the old world style pizza and you'll soon see what I'm talking about. Call the pizza place for the pizza.
Posted by Lucas F on 12/29/2013
This place is just around the corner from my place. I was excited to hopefully and finally get some good Italian cuisine in the hood but the food isn't good. Something as simple as a Caesar salad is lacking in flavor and freshness. Their vegetable sides seem to be frozen and it just seems like a generic place even though the menu is enticing.
Posted by anonymous on 12/27/2013
I think you get a good deal at Goodfellas. It is a lot less expensive than many other Italian restaurants in Gramercy and the Flatiron District and I feel you get good food for that price.
Posted by Maserati on 12/14/2013
The namesake has it wrong, it's Bad Fellas! What a shame, its a fairy new place in the hood but the food is forgettable. The chicken parm sandwich had a hardish roll that didn't seem so fresh and the chicken tasted and looked like it was frozen from a box. If I wanted that quality I could have saved money in the freezer section at my local supermarket. Also had the wings which were just bleh and bland.
Posted by Rev on 10/25/2013
They do a god job making you feel welcome and they are accommodating. However, much of the food was bland and lacked flavor. The ingredients didn't seem to be the highest quality.
Posted by Ryan F on 07/15/2013
I live directly across the street from GoodFellas and find it to be the best italian i can order in the neighborhood. Ive tried many places and i am a foodie.. and there is not anything better close by. The alavodka brick oven pizza is awesome... the Goodfellas chicken pasta is amazing.. i have had the raviolis, the wings, calamari, a few salads and everything was great. I have also eaten in there once and it has a great ambiance i would reccomend it to anyone who is looking for a great value for there italian meal. Delivery is fast as well.