
Hold down Control (PC) or Command (Mac) key + mouseclick to select more than one option
| Rating | Avg. Dinner Entrée |
|---|---|
| $$$$$ | Greater than $25 |
| $$$$ | $18.01 - $25 |
| $$$ | $12.01 - $18 |
| $$ | $7.01 - $12 |
| $ | Less than $7 |
Reviews from nymag.com
| Food | ![]() |
Value | ![]() |
|---|---|---|---|
| Service | ![]() |
Atmosphere | ![]() |
Posted by MurrayHillMan on 01/29/2010
Over priced and average
Recently took a new job in the neighborhood and walked past this place a few times so figured I'd stop in after work tonight. Ordered a bacon cheeseburger medium with fries ..no drink and the price was $11.50. The burger was about the size of a McD's Angus or 1/3d pounder and was almost raw on the inside. It tasted fine for $5 burb=ger but for $8.50 it tasted lousy!! With a drink I would have spent $14 or so..way way way too much considering the size and quality of the buger. Fries were short and stubby but pretty good and decently crispy. This $11.50 meal was worth $8.50 at most..I won't ever return!!
Posted by RLP on 06/09/2009
NOT so good anymore
I've been going to Goodburger for awhile now. Lately the burgers are thinner, and I don't think the veggie burgers are made fresh daily anymore. The burger meet isn't as tasty. The veggie burger is now super thin and has a perfect shape such a sign of a frozen patty.
Posted by liz on 04/01/2009
too expensive and not good
i got a turkey burger there and was totally disappointed. the price was exorbitant and was expecting an amazing burger. my burger was falling apart and there was nothing good about it. i got better burgers for $5 dollars at the no name places.
Posted by Anonymous on 01/17/2009
don't bother
This is another one of those places that rich people go to waste their money. For over $10 for a mediocre meal you could get elsewhere for cheaper it seems like people support good burger only for the location, atmosphere, and hype. Don't listen to the trendy rich folk that don't bother looking for good value. It's all hype!! Oh, and the fries are WHACK.
Posted by Anonymous on 10/31/2008
I gave them a few chances
But they screwed up one too many times. I would order from here occasionally over the past few years, when I got tired of my favorite diner. But each time they screwed up. Although they are only 1 block away, they never took less than 40 minutes to deliver. The burger was often NOT cooked as I specified, I have been given the wrong drink on more than one occasion, and they often screwed up on the toppings. I would only order once every few months after the memory of my previous bad experience faded, and they would just give me another to remind me. Last time. Not to mention they are overpriced and overrated.
Posted by Anon on 04/17/2008
Don't Believe the Naysayers!
I'm a burger-holic and GoodBurger is a great addition to the burger landscape. Agree with those who feel the fries are mediocre, but the burgers are perfect. Yes, buns are like Wonder and that's because burger buns should be like that. Those who try to make them all special by using thick and oversized buns ruin the all-important ratio of bread-to-meat. The burger always comes out exactly medium as I order it, even when I get it delivered. Now that's quite a feat! Try getting a burger medium these days - not easy. Usually too rare or too well-done. The mixed cheeses are delish as are the grilled onions. All-in-all, a great experience with very satisfying burgers. Improve the fries and it moves up the ladder even higher.
Posted by Anonymous on 04/01/2008
not a very good buger
Actually a very midiocre burger. Probably below the big chains for quality, selection, and speed of service. Don't see why you would go here unless you like paying more. Unfortunately this thing is located in a pretty good area, which means it probably won't go under.