Hold down Control (PC) or Command (Mac) key + mouseclick to select more than one option
Posted by Inwoodfoodie on 01/22/2014
So I have now ordered 3 times from George's over the course of the last year. I do not understand why this place is getting a lot of hype...marketing/reviews by the owners/employees perhaps? I found it perfectly mediocre. the dough was too thick and thus horribly undercooked. There was far too much sauce on the pizza which contributed to its wet, ooze-like texture. The price, however, was disproportionately high when considering quality. Thus, the overall value of the experience was diminished. I am certain that some of you have had positive experiences of this place, alas, after three attempts, I cannot count myself among such a select few.
Posted by gatormul on 09/14/2013
I love this place. I moved to the neighborhood 2 years ago and at first thought it was going to be like every other cheap place to get a slice. Boy was I wrong, and gladly so. The slices are good, but not as good as getting a pie. And so cheap, I couldn't believe how much I got for what I paid. For 2 people a medium will feed you for a couple of days, a Large...fugidaboudit. It always comes in about 15 minutes, so hot I have to let it cool for a little bit before I can eat it. Do not pass this place up.
Posted by Punch on 10/23/2011
This place had some of the tastiest pizza around, but it has gone down hill rapidly. The crust is now so thick that it doesn't always cook through. It's on the way home, otherwise I'd skip it entirely. Pity.
Posted by nightbreaker on 03/11/2011
everytime i go i think it's gonna be great and by the time i'm done i am almost clapping and always thanking the surly old dudes who are still back there making pies after all these decades. the bread is real, thick, could stand on its own as just great bread. and the sauce is perfect, sweet, actual tomato sauce, so amazing it sends me back to 20, 30 years to my childhood in coney island and a sauce i forgot until i tried this one. i am a kid again when i eat this slice, a kid who never took for granted the personal touch that great new york food has. and it's still cheap, more than worth it. love the hole in the wall of it, love the old men bitchin at each other hunched over the dough and sauce, love it. it is home.
Posted by anonymous on 11/06/2010
We do not recommend ordering delivery from George's. We've lived in the neighborhood for several years and were happy with them until recently. The last several times we've ordered from them the pizza has not been made fresh - it arrived cold and each slice was a different size; clearly thrown together from separate pies. Today we decided to try again and told them about what has happened recently, asked if they would make the pie fresh - they told us to come and make it ourselves. We will never order from them again.
Posted by posen on 10/01/2010
The service is straight forward and so is the food. I think George's pizza is amongst the best in the hood and the delivery is always lightening fast. The atmosphere is perfectly appropriate. Highly recommend!
Posted by Anonymous on 07/11/2010
Ordered delivery and it took forever. Ordered garlic knots and no sauce. Pizza tasted like cardboard.. Hmm nice try