Hold down Control (PC) or Command (Mac) key + mouseclick to select more than one option
Upper West Side >
Posted by Anonymous on 02/04/2009
To say that the food was pizza parlor quality would be complementary. For those of you who need a better explanation - the tomato sauce was sweet, as in full of sugar; the tuscan bread salad had no bread in it and instead was full of cucumbers and peppers, as in Greek salad, and the polenta was like soup, as in horrible. Enough said.
Posted by Anonymous on 01/06/2009
I disagee with several of the reviews - We absolutely fell in love with Gennaro's! The seating was cozy and romantic. The food was amazing (especially the world famous lamb shank!) and wasn't overpriced for the quality. We enjoyed that the wait staff didn't constantly bother us - they made sure that our glasses were never empty and that our food was to our liking, then left us to enjoy our meal and conversation. We will definately be back there again.
Posted by Foodie4321 on 12/24/2008
Overrated. Our food was nothing special. Pasta portions are tiny and over priced. Tables are way to close together. The service is obnoxious. Gave over a 20% tip then got forced to leave by the waiter and bus boy. Cash only = no receipt = they don't pay taxes. This place is great for upper west siders who want to be new yorkers and think they know good food. No reason to go back. Find another place.
Posted by NYDiners on 06/13/2008
The food is decent, but we will gladly spend a dollar or two more elsewhere to receive the same caliber of food (if not better) and some service. The floor staff at Gennaro have no clue about attentive service and are full of oversight, but boy do they expect your tip money regardless! Never again for this place!
Posted by Anonymous on 04/02/2008
I ate here last night for the first time and ordered my usual and favorite dish: rack of lamb. While the food was decent it was way too salty and a bad value for the price. The portions were so small I had to give my boyfriend some of my lamb because he was still hungry after eating his tiny pasta dish. What really bothered me was that they have a note on their menu that says $20 min per person which is just rude. The service was sub-par and for the price I know much better places I would rather go that don't have an annoying cash only policy.
Posted by Claudio - Canada on 03/25/2008
A couple of weeks ago we had the pleasure of dining twice at Gennaro's. The place was "hopping" on both occasions. The food was excellent... well portioned, well prepared, tasty trattoria style fare. Though a bit tight the seating is comfortable and the cheery wait staff managed to serve us in timely fashion despite having to negotiate the crowded surroundings. This "cozy" restaurant really made us feel at home. Bravissimi! On a side note we must mention that we forgot some NYC souvenirs under our table. No problem, after an email the conscientious management had our stuff in the mail to Canada in short order . Thanks Michael.
Posted by anonymous on 03/16/2008
I agree with recent comments. The food is decent, and well-priced, but certainly not worth the hassle anymore.