Welcome to MenuPages - Please Select a city:

Garden City Deli

  • $$
    RatingAvg. Dinner Entrée
    $$$$$Greater than $25
    $$$$$18.01 - $25
    $$$$12.01 - $18
    $$$7.01 - $12
    $Less than $7
  • Delis, Sandwiches, Salads
  • 607 9th Ave, New York NY10036 40.759203 -73.992203
  • (Btwn 43rd & 44th St)
  • click map to interact
  • (212) 974-0573
  • 0

Delivery & Take Out


Two Eggs On A Roll    1.99
Eggs With Breakfast Meat On A Roll    2.99
Two Egg Whites On A Roll    2.49
Grilled Vegetables & Eggs On A Roll    2.99
Western Omelet With Roll made with ham, onions & peppers.   3.99
Cheese Omelet With Roll    2.99
Pastrami Omelet With Roll    3.99
Croissant With Egg & Cheese    3.99
Greek Style Omelet With Roll feta cheese, fresh spinach & mushrooms.   3.99
Classic Egg Omelet With Roll ham & american cheese.   3.99
Healthy Egg Whites Omelet With Roll egg whites with oven roasted vegetables and fresh mushrooms.   3.99
Southern Style With Roll eggs with ham, cheddar cheese, green onions & salsa.   3.99
Turkey & Cheese Omelet With Roll    3.99
Bagel With Cream Cheese    1.95
Pancakes (3)    3.99
Two Egg Platter with home fries and toast.   3.99
Eggs With Breakfast Meat Platter served with home fries and toast.   4.99
Two Egg Whites Platter served with home fries and toast.   4.49
Grilled Vegetables & Eggs Platter served with home fries and toast.   5.99
Western Omelet Platter made with ham, onions & peppers. served with home fries and toast.   5.99
Cheese Omelet Platter served with home fries and toast.   4.99
Pastrami Omelet Platter served with home fries and toast.   5.99
Croissant With Egg & Cheese Platter served with home fries and toast.   5.99
Greek Style Omelet Platter feta cheese, fresh spinach & mushrooms. served with home fries and toast.   5.99
Classic Egg Omelet Platter ham & american cheese. served with home fries and toast.   5.99
Healthy Egg Whites Omelet Platter egg whites with oven roasted vegetables and fresh mushrooms. served with home fries and toast.   5.99
Southern Style Platter eggs with ham, cheddar cheese, green onions & salsa. served with home fries and toast.   5.99
Turkey & Cheese Omelet Platter served with home fries and toast.   5.99
Bagel With Fresh Salmon    4.95
French Toast (3)    3.99
Breakfast On A Wrap Option $1 (Plain, Whole Wheat, Spinach, Sun Dried Tomato)

Egg Wraps $4.45

Greek Style Wrap eggs, feta cheese, fresh spinach & mushrooms in a spinach wrap.   
Healthy Egg White Wrap egg whites with oven roasted vegetables & fresh mushrooms in a whole wheat wrap.   
Classic Egg Wrap eggs, ham, american cheese & home fries in an herb wrap.   
Southwestern Style Wrap eggs with ham, cheddar cheese, green onions & salsa in a roasted pepper wrap.   

Bagels, Muffins, Danish

Danish    2.00
Flavored Croissant    2.50
Scone    2.00
Fat Free Muffin    2.00
Croissant  plain.   2.00
Ham & Cheese Croissant    3.95
Jumbo Muffin    2.00

Bagel Or Bialy Add-On

With Bagel/Bialy Flavor: Plain, Sesame, Cinnamon Raisin, Poppy Seed, Whole Wheat, Everything.

Plain Cream Cheese    2.00
Scallion Cream Cheese    2.95
Smoked Norwegian Salmon & Cream Cheese    4.95
Vegetable Cream Cheese    2.95
Lox Spread    2.95


Soup Of The Day  reg 3.45lg 3.95

Garden City Fresh Salads

Reg / Lg

Garden City Special choice of 5 toppings. reg 6.95lg 7.95
Traditional Chef's Salad turkey, ham, swiss & american cheese, hard boiled egg & cucumbers over mixed greens.  lg 8.95
grilled and on a wrap   7.95
Pasta Salad pasta, cheddar cheese, broccoli, tomatoes & breaded chicken. reg 6.95lg 7.95
Turkey Club Salad romaine, swiss cheese, smoked turkey, bacon bits, grapes, tomatoes, croutons and ranch dressing. reg 7.95lg 8.95
grilled and on a wrap   7.95
Pesto Chicken Salad mesclun mix, pesto chicken, broccoli, sun-dried tomatoes, sliced almonds, red onions, olive oil & balsamic vinaigrette. reg 7.95lg 8.95
grilled and on a wrap   7.95
Garden City Salad romaine lettuce, tomato, carrots, cucumber, green pepper and olives. reg 6.50lg 6.95
with tuna salad or chicken salad or grilled chicken reg 7.95lg 8.95
Greek Salad crisp lettuce, feta cheese, stuffed grape leaves, tomatoes, olives & onions.   7.95
Classic Cobb Salad oven roasted turkey, avocado, crumbled blue cheese, mushrooms, carrots & bacon over mixed greens.  lg 8.95
grilled and on a wrap   7.95
Southern Chicken Salad cajun chicken, blue cheese, tomatoes, mushrooms & corn. reg 6.95lg 7.95
grilled and on a wrap   7.95
Healthy Tuna Salad romaine, italian tuna, avocado, chickpeas, carrots & vinaigrette. reg 7.50lg 8.50
on a wrap   7.95
Ranch Salad romaine, breaded chicken, avocado, egg whites, sliced tomatoes, toasted almonds and balsamic vinaigrette sauce. reg 7.95lg 8.95
grilled and on a wrap   7.95
Caesar Salad  reg 4.95lg 6.95
with grilled chicken reg 6.95lg 7.95
grilled and on a wrap   7.95

Salad Toppings

Grilled Lemon Chicken    
Grilled BBQ Chicken    
Grilled Teriyaki Chicken    
Maple Honey Turkey Breast    
Peppermill Turkey Breast    
Black Forest Ham    
Italian Tuna    
Portobello Mushroom    
Marinated Artichoke Hearts    
Imported Feta Cheese    
Fresh Avocado    
Stuffed Grape Leaves    
Roasted Peppers    
Pesto Sauce    
Parmesan Cheese    
Plum Tomatoes    
Bell Peppers    
Fresh Corn    
Kidney Beans    
Fresh Broccoli    
Grilled Herb Chicken    
Grilled Mexican Chicken    
Oven Roasted Turkey Breast    
Smoked Turkey Breast    
Chicken Cutlet    
Fresh Mozzarella    
White Tuna    
Bacon Bits    
Sun-Dried Tomatoes    
Sliced Beets    
Cheddar Cheese    
Kalamata Olives    
Cherry Tomatoes    
Sunflower Seeds    
Chick Peas    
Green Peas    
Sweet Peas    
Hard Boiled Egg    

Just Falafel

Falafel Pocket salad & hummus.   4.95
Falafel Mexicano avocado, jalapeno, red onions, tomato & lettuce.   5.95
Falafel Platter salad, grape leaves, hummus & baba ganoush.   7.95
Falafel Wrap salad & hummus.   5.95
Falafel Burger lettuce, tomato, pickle, cheese & mayo.   5.95
Chicken & Appetizer grilled chicken, grilled vegetables, salad, hummus & baba ganoush.   9.95

Paninis $7.95

Served On European Flat Bread With Potato Chips And A Pickle.

The Teriyaki grilled chicken with grilled vegetables. jarlsberg cheese & teriyaki sauce.   
Tuscan fresh mozzarella, fresh plum tomatoes, fresh basil, fresh spinach & fresh sun-dried tomato spread.   
Delightful fresh honey-glazed turkey, jarlsberg cheese, cole slaw & honey mustard.   
Toasted Monte Cristo layers of ham & smoked turkey, swiss & cheddar cheese, lettuce, tomatoes & honey mustard.   
The Alpino black forest ham, alpine swiss cheese, grilled vegetables & lemon herb dressing.   
Capri smoked turkey, pepperoni, provolone cheese, spinach, cherry peppers & balsamic vinaigrette.   
Meatless fresh mozzarella, fresh plum tomatoes, fresh basil, fresh spinach & sun-dried tomato spread.   
Chicken Parmigian breaded chicken, fresh mozzarella, marinara sauce, fresh basil & parmesan cheese.   
Tuna Melt fresh tuna salad, cheddar cheese, lettuce & plum tomatoes.   
Chicken Fajita grilled chicken, cheddar cheese, roasted peppers, caramelized onions & salsa.   
Chicken Club grilled chicken, smoked bacon, brie cheese, plum tomatoes & house dressing.   
Siciliano prosciutto, ham, mozzarella, sun-dried tomatoes, arugula & creamy balsamic vinaigrette.   
The Combo pastrami, corned beef, provolone cheese, lettuce, tomatoes, mustard & house dressing.   
The Italiano grilled chicken, roasted peppers, fresh mozzarella & pesto sauce.   

Wraps $7.95

Served With Potato Chips And A Pickle.

Arizona chicken cutlet, pepper jack cheese, hot peppers, lettuce, tomatoes & herb mayo.   
American roast beef, turkey, american & swiss cheese, lettuce & tomatoes.   
Caesar grilled chicken and caesar dressing.   
B.B.Q. Chicken sliced barbecue chicken breast, avocado, romaine lettuce, jack cheese & sun-dried tomato sauce.   
South Western cajun chicken, avocado, cheddar cheese and ranch dressing.   
Veggie green zucchini, yellow squash, red, yellow & green peppers with hummus.   
Sicilian grilled chicken, peppers & onions.   
E.Z.Z.  grilled chicken, sun-dried tomato, fresh basil, fresh mozzarella & honey mustard.   
Steak Wrap premium roast beef, grilled with sauteed onions, peppers & bbq sauce.   
Willy Pick grilled chicken, grilled vegetables, avocado, fresh cilantro, swiss cheese and ranch dressing.   

Popular Picks $7.95

Served With Potato Chips And A Pickle.

Spicy Grilled Chicken lettuce, hot peppers & tabasco sauce, mozzarella and grilled onion.   
Chicken Cutlet Parmigiana chicken cutlet with melted mozzarella & special parmigiana sauce.   
Woods black forest ham, alpine lace cheese, sun dried tomato, spinach & honey mustard.   
Smoked Turkey Breast brie cheese, leaf lettuce, plum tomatoes & honey mustard.   
Fresh Mozzarella sun-dried tomatoes, fresh basil leaves, roasted peppers, extra virgin olive oil & cracked black pepper.    
Chef's Pick grilled chicken breast with avocado, roasted red peppers, mesclun & ranch dressing.   
Chicken Cheddar chicken cutlet with melted cheddar cheese, crispy bacon, lettuce & tomato.   
Santa Fe spicy turkey, fresh mozzarella, basil, tomato & balsamic vinaigrette.   
Russian roast beef, muenster cheese, caramelized onions, lettuce, plum tomatoes & russian dressing.   

Specialty Sandwiches $7.95

Grilled Breast Of Chicken honey mustard, roasted peppers, shredded carrots, plum tomatoes & leaf lettuce on a light country sourdough bread.   
Fresh Roasted Turkey with fresh spinach, honey mustard & plum tomatoes on a country sourdough bread.   
Old Fashioned Tuna roasted peppers, leaf lettuce & plum tomatoes on an eight grain baguette.   
Prime Beef grilled roast beef with melted american cheese, lettuce, tomato and grilled onion.   
Chicken Caesar gilled chicken breast topped with caesar salad & roasted peppers on ciabatta bread.   
Chicken Cordon Bleu chicken cutlet and grilled honey baked ham with melted mozzarella cheese, grilled onion, lettuce & tomato.   
Black Forest Ham imported swiss cheese, leaf lettuce, plum tomatoes & mustard on 7 grain bread.   

Grilled Subs

Served With Potato Chips And A Pickle.

Garden City Steak chunk of roast beef, sauteed onions, peppers, mushrooms & bbq sauce.   8.95
New York Pastrami american cheese, sauerkraut & honey mustard dressing on rye.   7.95
Classic Turkey turkey breast, sauteed onions, peppers, mushrooms corn & ranch.   7.95
Teriyaki Chicken roasted peppers & sauteed onions.   7.95
Premium Roast Beef sauteed onions, peppers, cheddar cheese & russian dressing.   7.95
Reuben corn beef, swiss cheese, sauerkraut & russian dressing on rye.   7.95
Meatballs Sub    7.95
Cajun Chicken roasted peppers & sauteed onions.   7.95

Philly Steak $7.95

Served With Potato Chips And A Pickle.

Original Philly with onions, peppers & mozzarella cheese.   
Mexican Steak with onions, peppers, jalapeno, avocado & monterey jack cheese.   
Texas Steak onions, peppers, mozzarella & bbq sauce.   
Italian Steak with onions, peppers, marinara sauce & mozzarella.   
Chicken Steak grilled chicken with onions, peppers & cheese.   


Reg / Lg

Hamburger   3.95 6.95
Bacon Cheese Burger   5.95 8.95
Vegetarian Burger   5.95 8.95
Cheese Burger   4.95 7.95
Turkey Burger   5.95 7.95

Maximopino Gelato & Sorbetto

Sm $3.99 / Reg $4.99 / Lg $5.99

Vanilla Gelato    
Coffee Gelato    
Mint Chocolate Chip Gelato    
Hazelnut Cream Gelato    
Coconut Sorbetto    
Strawberry Sorbetto    
Chocolate Gelato    
Cookies N' Cream Gelato    
Stracciatella Gelato    
Tiramisu Gelato    
Raspberry Sorbetto    
Mango Sorbetto    

Fruit Smoothies

Reg $3.45 / Lg $4.45


Coffee & Tea

Reg $2.50 / Lg $3.

House Coffee    
Steamed Hot Chocolate    
Iced Tea    
Flavored Coffee    
Iced Coffee    


Soda pepsi, diet pepsi, caffeine free diet pepsi, coke, diet coke, gingerale, diet gingerale, 7-up, diet 7-up, seltzer water, sprite. can 1.25(20oz btl) 1.95
16oz. Bottled Water volvic, evian.   1.95
poland springs   1.25


Delivery & Take Out - Salad Bar

Reg $3.50 / $4.50. Choose From Romaine Or Mixed Greens. Tossed Salads Made To Order Your Way. Served With Free Bread.

Salad Dressing

Creamy Italian    
Sesame Ginger    
Creamy Russian    
Peppercorn Blue Cheese    
Balsamic Vinaigrette    
Creamy Ranch    
Roasted Garlic    
Creamy French    
Honey Mustard    
Olive Oil & Vinegar    

Low-Fat Salad Dressing

Light Italian    
Fat-Free Lemon Herb    
Fat-Free Raspberry Vinaigrette    
Fat-Free Thousand Island    

Cheese $1.50

Salad Bar Cheese Option

Fresh Mozzarella    
Imported Feta Cheese    
Cheddar Cheese    
Parmesan Cheese    

Meat $2

Salad Bar Meats Option

Grilled Lemon Chicken    
Grilled Herb Chicken    
Grilled Teriyaki Chicken    
Oven Roasted Turkey Breast    
Maple Honey Turkey Breast    
Smoked Turkey Breast    
Peppermill Turkey Breast    
Chicken Cutlet    
Black Forest Ham    
Italian Tuna    
White Tuna    

Veggies, Beans, Egg, Etc. $0.75

Salad Bar Veggies, Beans, Egg, Etc. Option

Portobello Mushroom    
Bacon Bits    
Marinated Artichoke Hearts    
Sun-Dried Tomatoes    
Sliced Beets    
Fresh Avocado    
Stuffed Grape Leaves    
Kalamata Olives    
Roasted Peppers    
Pesto Sauce    
Cherry Tomatoes    
Sunflower Seeds    
Chick Peas    
Plum Tomatoes    
Bell Peppers    
Green Peas    
Fresh Corn    
Sweet Peas    
Kidney Beans    
Hard Boiled Egg    
Fresh Broccoli    


Delivery & Take Out - Create Your Own Favorite Sandwich

Choose Between Bread, Roll, Wrap, Hero Or Panini, Then Choose 1 Cheese And 3 Toppings.

Roll kaiser, whole wheat, poppyseed   6.95
Hero    7.95
Panini    7.95
Bread white, whole wheat, rye.   6.95
Wrap plain, whole wheat, spinach, sun-dried tomato.   7.95


Yellow American    
Fresh Mozzarella    
Pepper Jack    


Roasted Turkey    
Smoked Turkey    
Honey Glazed Turkey    
Pepper Turkey    
Sausalito Turkey    
Breaded Chicken Breast    
Grilled Chicken Breast    
BBQ Chicken Breast    
Cajun Chicken Breast    
Teriyaki Chicken Breast    
Chicken Salad    
Corned Beef    
Beef Salami    
Hard Salami    
Boiled Ham    
Spice Ham    
Baked Virginia Ham    


Roasted Peppers    
Red Onion    
Shredded Carrots    
Green Peppers    
Red Peppers    


Honey Mustard    
Balsamic Vinaigrette    
Olive Oil    


Free Can Of Soda

Diet Pepsi    
Caffeine Free Diet Pepsi    
Diet Coke    
Diet Gingerale    
Diet 7-Up    


Delivery & Take Out - Create Your Favorite Parfait

Reg $3.95 / Lg $4.95. Vanilla Frozen Yogurt Topped With 2 Kinds Of Fresh Fruit & 2 Dry Toppings. Make it Shake: Vanilla Frozen Yogurt Blended With Your Favorite Fresh Fruits.

Fresh Fruit

Fruit Parfait Or Yogurt Shake Fresh Fruit Option


Dry Topping

Fruit Parfait Or Yogurt Shake Dry Topping Option

Dried Cranberries    


Garden City Deli
607 9th Ave
Btwn 43rd & 44th St
(212) 974-0573
© 2015 GrubHub, Inc. All rights reserved.