Hold down Control (PC) or Command (Mac) key + mouseclick to select more than one option
Reviews from nymag.com
Posted by sch1775 on 06/22/2010
pretentious waiters, and horrible food. will not go back
Posted by anonymous on 06/08/2010
I wouldn't have minded payint the $25.oo for the lobster roll, if there was a decent portion of lobster. HOWEVER, there wasn't even 3 bites in the skimpy roll. The plate was loaded with lettuce and potato chips. Very cheesy. Staff was lovely, but I had to eat when I got home! Will not TRY again.
Posted by MAXIMILIAN on 05/24/2010
Came here with my parents and we had a very nice meal. The service was top quality and everything was handled very nicely. It was a quite night, which may have led to such staff attentiveness, but the food was also great. We each had a different piece of fish, each prepared perfectly and ended up all sharing bites. The place is a bit pricey, but I think it's worth it. It's a place that gives top quality in return for the money. Recommended.
Posted by Rose on 05/09/2010
My husband and I recently went to Fulton for what turned out to be a very disappointing dinner. First, we had to wait 15 minutes while the staff set up our empty table. Then, I placed my order for salmon, cooked medium, with sauce on the side. It arrived very rare, sitting in a pool of sauce. I sent it back, and the waitress said they would give me a new piece. However, when my fish came back, it was clear that it was the same piece. The manager came over, and after an argument, she said I could have a new piece of fish. This time I ordered a different kind, which came 20 minutes later, during which time my husband finished his entire meal. By this time the staff at the restaurant was ignoring us. I was extremely disappointed with the food and the service, and needless to say, I won't be going back!
Posted by Sushi Lover on 04/04/2010
If youre in the mood for a great fish meal this is the place to go. I had the hamachi appetizer and it was so fresh & delicious. Then I ordered the branzino, I had the filet it and I thought the piece of fish was a nice portion. It was also very tasty. It came with a sides of sea salt, oil, and lemon so you could add it on as you liked. I thought the presentation was very nice. My husband got the grilled octopus as an appetizer and it was very yummy. The service was just okay but we sat outside and when you sit outside you don't always get the same attention. They have a great outdoor area that is quiet and wasn't as crowded on such a beautiful night like atlantic grill was.
Posted by shiradavid on 12/25/2009
Went there just before Christmas with friends. Food was very uneven and on average no better than mediocre: my wife's cod was very good, my wild sea bass was pretty sub-par, the sardine appetizer nothing to write home abt. The apple pie was one of the worst I had in over a decade, my friend's chocolate mousse was pretty good. Nice, simple and tasteful decor (may come across as a bit too spartan for some but I liked it). Waiter was pretty unfriendly and snotty, at times bordering on the insolent with his looks. Definitely not worth the price -we paid $100 per person incl tip and a single bottle of wine. Will not be going back.
Posted by anonymous on 09/29/2009
I live around the corner and often dine at Fulton. The past 2 times I've been though the food seems better than ever and desserts are outstanding. Do not miss the apple pie!