Hold down Control (PC) or Command (Mac) key + mouseclick to select more than one option
Upper East Side >
Posted by Anonymous on 09/01/2008
Having read the reviews here made me choose to go to Firenze. But the experience did not live up to the reviews. First of all, despite the assurances of the waiter, the AC was not working and the front door was wide open. The room is dark and better suited to a cold winter night than a warm summer evening. The food all seemed to be sauced with the same sauce (or at least a close variation). we had 3 different veal dishes and all were sauced with a brown/creamy sauce that tasted the same on all three dishes. This was also similar to the bosciola sauce on the pasta. It wasn't bad but it certainly did not say much for the inventivness of the chef. The focaccia was the best and the service was fine. But we probably won't be back.
Posted by Wonderful on 08/11/2008
Great italian food. The hostess was very warm and attentive. Our server could have been more attentive, however he had 7 tables in his section. Strongly recommend the pasta primavera.
Posted by out of towners on 07/05/2008
Left a message on a machine for a same night reservation on a Friday and received a prompt callback confirmation. Having been to Italy, we enjoy good food and wine al fresco. Nice selection of red wines by the glass. Dinner was awesome. the fresh berries with zabilogne for dessert was plenty for 2 and delicious.. The limoncello after dinner took us right back to Sorrento. Service was friendly, but not overbearing. We ordered several things we didn't know the prices of, so weren't quite sure what to expect when the bill came, but were pleasantly surprised. Wished we lived closer, it would become one of our regulars.
Posted by New to NYC on 05/04/2008
I tried this restaurant for the first time on a busy Sat night and we were (party of 2) seated right away. The service was great- everyone was so nice and friendly. The setting was my favorite- very cozy, old world Italian- perfect for the rainy night it was. We got drinks, bread and our food right away. My only complaint was at the end when I was still finishing my glass of wine and the manager basically asked us if we were done. They were in a hurry to seat another party. All in all, I would definitely go back. The menu choices were awesome!
Posted by Park Avenue Snob on 02/17/2008
My husband has dietary limitations. He ordered his entire dinner off the menu. Instead of sounding like a middle aged man with a high cholesterol problem, he sounded like a pretentious Upper East Sider. The waiter and chef were excellent. Accommodative, and pampering. My meal was delicious. As we walked out of the restaurant, my husband said that he was treated like a King. Nicest compliment he ever gave a restaurant.
Posted by Beberstone on 10/31/2007
A couple of friends had recommended this restaurant, and we had been meaning to try it for months. We finally had the chance and it was well worth the wait. The quaint atmosphere was warm and welcoming. The staff did not rush to make us order, we were able to enjoy each other's company. The specials were so appetizing, it was hard to decide. Then menu was not huge, but filled with delicious choices. Everything we ordered arrived quickly, was hot, and tasted AMAZING. We devoured everything! But, even when we were done, we sat pleasantly without being hurried to pay the check…which is so nice in busy nyc. We hope to become regulars here.
Posted by Anonymous on 10/01/2007
The food was great and once we sat down the service was great, but I called two weeks in advance to make my reservation for 12 people and we still had to wait an hour to sit down. The place is small and very charming, but would NEVER go back with a big group. To be fare, the staff was very accomodating and, after my insistance, bought our appetizers and gave us all free wine while we waited. I saw even tables of 2 with reservations waiting, so definitly make that reservation and show up on time. Without the wait it might have been 5's all around.