Welcome to MenuPages - Please Select a city:

Firehouse Tavern

  • RatingAvg. Dinner Entrée
    $$$$$Greater than $25
    $$$$$18.01 - $25
    $$$$12.01 - $18
    $$$7.01 - $12
    $Less than $7
  • American (Traditional), Mexican, Wings
  • 522 Columbus Ave, NEW YORK NY10024 40.786074 -73.972693
  • (Btwn 85th & 86th St)
  • click map to interact
  • (212) 787-3473
  • 0

User Ratings (Based on 46 reviews)

Food 3.7 Value 3.8
Service 3.4 Atmosphere 3.2

Other Restaurant Info

(212) 787-3473
(212) 362-3004
Place Order:
Order From Firehouse for delivery & takeout
Visa, MC, AmEx
Sun-Thu: 11:30am-11pm Sat: 11:30am-1pm
Lunch, Dinner
Kid-friendly, Open Late, Outdoor Dining, Delivery, Online Ordering, Wheelchair Friendly, Accepts Credit Cards, Lunch Special, Take Out
Min Delivery:

User Reviews

  • Firehouse Tavern

    Posted by Amelia Eve on 12/19/2010

    My Favorite Cheese Burger

    I love these burgers. Honest and beefy, and a generous quantity of really great quality cheddar cheese. And the kitchen is willing to serve it truly rare. The menu here is limited, but it's all very well done. Good nachos, good wings, good burritos, OK pizza. I do agree that the beer list could be more interesting -- I usually have the Woodchuck cider, but some craft brews would make it more appealing.

  • Firehouse Tavern

    Posted by olshef on 09/12/2010

    don't waste your money or time

    Worst place in town....food was awful, and the service was worst. The waitress chastised the table for sitting there too long and not ordering enough food.

  • Firehouse Tavern

    Posted by Morningside Diner on 08/28/2010

    Not worth it, even with a discount.

    I recently dined here after receiving a restaurant.com coupon and was extremely disappointed. First, the positives. The wings, as other reviewers mention, are very good, a rarity for Manhattan. The decor is interesting and it's a plus that they are dog-friendly. Overall, the food is passable, and while the prices aren't too bad they're high for the quality of food they serve. Chicken sandwich is ok but not worth $11. The "steak" quesadilla tastes like pot roast with low-quality jack cheese. My biggest complaint is the service. The two individuals standing at the door didn't greet us, and when we asked for a table for two they didn't hand us menus and just told us to "sit anywhere." As far as the table service goes, I don't expect a waitress to hold a conversation with me, but ours barely greeted us and provided very slow service. When we received our bill we were charged for extra soda. I asked if they charged for refills and the response was "yes." She should have offered up that information when she asked if we wanted a refill, but it wasn't a problem. I was content with her answer, but after she rang up our check she very rudely came back and explained that they give one free refill and charge for the rest. I'm not sure why she needed to get an attitude to explain their ridiculous policy (which I know isn't her decision) but the end of the meal is the worst time to be rude to customers as far as tipping is concerned, something any decent waitress would understand. There are just too many other restaurants in the area to settle for poor service and so-so food. I will not return.

  • Firehouse Tavern

    Posted by anonymous on 08/03/2010


    I placed an order for delivery and about 45 mins later i called to see if my order was on its way. The woman on the phone told me that the were really busy and waiting for the bus boy to finish his job to run the order out. I sad how long wil this take, should i just cancel my order? She proceeded to tell me that my order was made and i just had to wait. RUDE. The the delivery boy called me saying he didnt know my adress. After 30mins after my food arrived, the phone rings from the delievry boy prank calling me....i was very shocked at the rudeness and disrespect. To top it all of the food wasnt very good.

  • Firehouse Tavern

    Posted by Dan on 07/26/2010

    Watch out for the Chicken

    The wings here are always good..my companion ordered a chicken dish and the chicken was quite pink and under done. The waitress was very good about taking it back, but the manager was not as pleasant at having to take back the dish...overall not bad but the manager is not so hot

  • Firehouse Tavern

    Posted by Bugs on 05/23/2010

    Too busy

    "Hi, I'm sorry but we're just too busy to serve you now." (as the girl there just said to me) That's ok, since there are 6000 other places to eat in the city. We'll try you again in a few months, maybe...

  • Firehouse Tavern

    Posted by Jesse from 81st on 05/22/2010

    Very Pleased

    Their Barbecue Chicken pizza was excellent. Perfect blend of tangy barbecue sauce, cilantro, onion, and cheese. The cesar salad was great and the wings were just as solid. I will be ordering from this place again.

© 2015 GrubHub, Inc. All rights reserved.