MenuPages

awesome diner, food was great, the waiter was sexy lol the service is great everything alright cant complain

This is an excellent neighborhood diner; exactly the kind of place that is disappearing due to the onslaught of fast food chains and high rents. We need to support these places, and this one has the friendliest, most attentive service around. Those who want fancier restaurants have plenty of choices in the Slope; this is a diner, and it's just what a real diner should be. (That, to the person who wrote the last comment, is why they're still around).

Overpriced Wal-Mart-level food (more than $19 for feedlot London broil that's stringy and tough--seriously?) Waitresses are friendly, but that doesn't really make up for the poor quality of the food. With so many restaurant choices in this area (including another 24-hour diner just one block away), I'm sort of amazed they're in business.

My girlfriend and I are regulars - we have breakfast here almost every weekend. We order some combo of the California, Garden, and Spanish omelettes, which are always well-made and offered with the healthier option of grits instead of potatoes, something we haven't found at other diners. It makes for a very hearty, satisfying meal at a reasonable price. We love the photos of old Park Slope on the walls, which prompted us to buy a book full of the same. Service is always prompt, friendly, and courteous with plenty of coffee refills. There's a second room for overflow, so even at peak brunch hour, there's no wait for seating. Eat here once, and you'll want to return!

As someone who has grown up in Brooklyn and has probably been to almost all the diners in Brooklyn, Fifth Avenue Diner has the best food without a doubt.Their portions are huge and their quality is always fresh and delicious. Breakfast always hits the spot and the coffee mug is always full. I have also been there for dinner and have tried a number of different entrees. My favorite is the romainian steak dinner. It's a ridiculously huge cut of steak with potatoes and veggies and a salad for like 18 bucks. The waiters are attentive and the owners seem to know everyone who walks through the door. They have been here since 1972 so it's also expected.

Absolutely my favorite diner in the Slope. (I do love one other diner more but it is in Windsor Terrace, technically). 5th Ave Diner serves quality meals at a great value. They never fail.

Went on a Sunday for breakfast. We had eggs benedict,grits, eggs over easy,sausage..all was great! Oh, let's not forget the bargain bloody marys..$3 the day we went! The service was attentive and the food great! I can't wait to go back and take my son and daughter-in-law!