Welcome to MenuPages - Please Select a city:

Fat Witch Bakery

At the Chelsea Market
  • RatingAvg. Dinner Entrée
    $$$$$Greater than $25
    $$$$$18.01 - $25
    $$$$12.01 - $18
    $$$7.01 - $12
    $Less than $7
  • Bakeries
  • 75 9th Ave, New York NY10011 40.741964 -74.004793
  • (At 16th St)
  • click map to interact
  • (212) 807-1335
  • 0

User Ratings (Based on 6 reviews)

Food 3.3 Value 2.3
Service 3.5 Atmosphere 2.6

Other Restaurant Info

(212) 807-1335
Delivery Take Out Visa, MC, AmEx
Mon-Fri: 10am-9pm Sat: 10am-8pm Sun: 10am-7pm
Accepts Credit Cards, Delivery, Kid Friendly, Take Out

User Reviews

  • Fat Witch Bakery

    Posted by Kathy Ayers on 05/08/2015

    Change your shipping opts

    Please go back and use ups again. The cost is not that much and your brownies do arrive earlier than usps. I used fed ex on my last order and total travel time was 4 days. thank u

  • Fat Witch Bakery

    Posted by Najwa Ghani on 12/11/2013


    Not worth it for the price and they are oily when opened

  • Fat Witch Bakery

    Posted by RADCHEF on 08/01/2012

    This is not a brownie

    I purchased the 1 # bag of Witch Ends. These were the most tasteless brownie ever. There is a faint chocolate flavor. They were dry and crumbly. The color was pale, not the dark fudgy color of a proper brownie. You are better off with a box mix. Very disappointed.

  • Fat Witch Bakery

    Posted by Dedicated Brownie Lover on 09/18/2010

    Overpriced and Icky

    Im not saying this to be a hater. I'm a dedicated brownie lover and I just didn't like Fat Witches' brownies or blondies. I had a brownie craving yesterday and traveled down to Chelsea Market that evening solely to taste Fat Witch for the first time. I bought both the Fat Witch & Blonde Witch in regular 3+ ounce size. Neither version was good. Both were bland and starchy. The Duncan Hines brownies I make out of the box are definitely softer, smoother, and fudgier. The Blonde Witch was by far the worst, hardly edible, I ate two bites and tossed it. Unfortunately, this was an expensive adventure into mediocre sweets. At $2.50 for each regular sized square I was even more disappointed. My advice is that, if you go at all, buy the mini witches for $1.50 each just to test the waters of your taste buds. I guarantee that a mini square will tell you all you need to know.

  • Fat Witch Bakery

    Posted by Anonymous on 09/01/2009

    On my pillow at 60 Thompson!

    When I stayed at 60 Thompson, every evening when I came in there was the most wonderful treat from Fat Witch sitting on my pillow! Over the course of my stay, I had a variety of blondies and brownies. They were so good that the hotel could of been a hostel and I wouldn't of cared!

  • Fat Witch Bakery

    Posted by michelle on 06/26/2009

    amazing brownies

    these brownies are soo good! they make some of them fresh and majoirty of them are pre packaged. i've had all of them and my favorite is the blondie. sooo good!

© 2015 GrubHub, Inc. All rights reserved.