Welcome to MenuPages - Please Select a city:

Fat Sal's Pizza

  • RatingAvg. Dinner Entrée
    $$$$$Greater than $25
    $$$$$18.01 - $25
    $$$$12.01 - $18
    $$$7.01 - $12
    $Less than $7
  • Pizza, Italian
  • 1603 2nd Ave, New York NY10028 40.776116 -73.953135
  • (Btwn 83rd & 84th St)
  • click map to interact
  • (646) 963-9137
  • 0

User Ratings (Based on 36 reviews)

Food 3.3 Value 3.3
Service 2.9 Atmosphere 2.1

Other Restaurant Info

(646) 963-9137
Place Order:
Order From Fat Sal's Pizza for delivery & takeout
Delivery Take Out Catering Visa, MC, AmEx, Disc
Sun-Mon: 11am-11pm Tue-Sat: 11am-4am
Dinner, Lunch
Accepts Credit Cards, Catering, Delivery, Free Delivery, Late Night, Online Ordering, Open 7 Days, Take Out
Delivery Area:
66th to 98th St East River to 5th Ave

User Reviews

  • Fat Sal's Pizza

    Posted by Karen37 on 08/04/2014

    Yummy Yum

    The stuffed shells are so delicious and the portion given is superior to the price of the plate. Garlic Bread is also recommended. It takes a while to get your food but that is because they make orders fresh! Worth the wait.

  • Fat Sal's Pizza

    Posted by anonymous on 02/28/2014

    Bad service

    Waited 25 minutes to pick up one order of 10 BBQ wings. When I got home, found out they were plain wings.

  • Fat Sal's Pizza

    Posted by notzagat on 05/06/2013

    Not recommended, again

    Followup on review 2 yrs ago. Same tasteless, greasy, overcheesed under sauced very large pie. Delivery prompt, no more plates or free red pepper. Same pricing. Like every other pizzeria on Upper East Side--no good pizza here.

  • Fat Sal's Pizza

    Posted by Anonymous on 08/10/2012

    Mine is always a great pie!

    We get the fat sals special. We all like a mix of meat and veggies. We get our agreed five ingredients and the pie is devoured in no time! The pie is fresh, hot, and the crust is soft and chewy! It's great pizza... Period! Have not had had much else from sals nor have I been to the place itself, but delivery always works great for us!

  • Fat Sal's Pizza

    Posted by JoAn on 02/24/2012

    Oh, please! Fat Sal's is fantastic!

    I am a native new yorker who has eaten so much pizza that it's a wonder that I'm not a fat pig....and, Fat Sal's is really up there as top five pizzas in NYC. It's fantastic. Have even tried the 10th str location and it's great too. Delivery is fast and pizza is always hot. Anyone who is not getting their pizza on time is probably ordering on Superbowl Sunday!

  • Fat Sal's Pizza

    Posted by Anonymous on 01/31/2012

    Not recommended

    We ordered from Fat Sal's and after an hour and a half our pizza never came! We called and were told multiple times our order was on the way. Finally, we told the person on the phone to cancel our order - it showed up anyway. 1 hour and 45 minutes afetr we ordered. And, we only live 7 blocks away.

  • Fat Sal's Pizza

    Posted by M. on 01/05/2012

    Never Again

    I have ordered from this place numerous times before, and while they USED to have great food and service, they have gotten steadily worse. Tonight was the last straw. After having placed my order and waiting an hour for delivery I call them up and ask about the status. I get nothing but attitude from the guy on the phone who them proceeds to hang up on me. When my order does arrive, what I recieve can hardly be described as anything that resembles food. The pizza was ice cold and completely smashed against the box lid. Needless to say, I sent it back. I will never order from here again and would recommed that anyone reading this review just order from Roma's instead.

© 2015 GrubHub, Inc. All rights reserved.