Hold down Control (PC) or Command (Mac) key + mouseclick to select more than one option
Midtown West >
Fat Sal's Pizza
Posted by ckny on 09/06/2010
this is my first time ordering from this place. i ordered calamari that smelled like feet and tasted one.... it was so dry and tough my jaws hurt! i've never been that picky about food from a pizzeria, but this was so disgusting i threw it out.
Posted by anonymous on 05/30/2010
Pizza is very good to excellent with good toppings. Garlic knots not the best. Eggplant parm is good, meatballs above average. It's just a small pizzeria. The service is great though. Great people.
Posted by jayjay on 10/12/2007
if you are one to get over looks, come and try their food. Pizza is one of the best I had in years. The food is fresh and of great quality. Go for the eggplant parm. We order all the time, and are never disappointed.
Posted by Ziggy on 02/05/2006
Called at 7:30pm on Super Bowl Sunday. The guy that answered the phone was friendly and efficient. Food came in record time and was actually pretty good. This is highly unusual for a pizza joint during the Super Bowl in NYC
Posted by tiffany on 06/20/2005
This place has one of the best pizza's I've had in new york. I'm hooked...
Posted by lovezfood on 02/07/2005
Dough was way too thick and they overcharged us a couple bucks for each pie. Many other better choices in the hood.