Welcome to MenuPages - Please Select a city:

Fat Sal's Pizza

  • RatingAvg. Dinner Entrée
    $$$$$Greater than $25
    $$$$$18.01 - $25
    $$$$12.01 - $18
    $$$7.01 - $12
    $Less than $7
  • Pizza, Italian
  • 510 9th Ave, New York NY10018 40.756219 -73.994054
  • (Btwn 38th & 39th St)
  • click map to interact
  • (212) 594-9462
  • 0

User Ratings (Based on 10 reviews)

Food 3.5 Value 3.5
Service 3.4 Atmosphere 2.6

Other Restaurant Info

(212) 594-9462
Delivery Take Out Visa, MC, AmEx
Sun-Thu: 11am-10:30pm Fri-Sat: 11am-12am
Accepts Credit Cards, Delivery, Lunch, Lunch Special, Take Out
Delivery Area:
42nd St to 24th St 5th Ave to the Hudson River

User Reviews

  • Fat Sal's Pizza

    Posted by S.C. on 08/23/2012

    Group Delivery

    Made an order for a team lunch, 2 hours in advance, on Seamless - the food came promptly at 1pm. We got two pies, both of very decent quality and the best value for this area. We also got 2 large tossed salads which were of very poor quality - chopped iceberg, canned olives, canned roasted peppers and large slices of tomatoes (the included green peppers were missing) - totally tasteless, not a very good value for $7 each. Looking at the other salads, they include all the 5 same ingredients, so they are likely all not very good. I would definitely order pizzas and other menu items again, but would give the salads a miss.

  • Fat Sal's Pizza

    Posted by Anonymous on 06/28/2011

    The right slice

    The right slice that always hits the mark!

  • Fat Sal's Pizza

    Posted by Anonymous on 10/02/2008

    Great portions great price

    The food is delicious and the portions are enormous. Very friendly staff accommodating and speedy. A great deal for classic Italian food!

  • Fat Sal's Pizza

    Posted by selmax on 06/19/2008

    Pretty poor

    Soggy, greasy French fries. Doughy pizza with overly sweet sauce that tastes like marinara. Screwed up delivery. You'd have to be starving to think this place has good food.

  • Fat Sal's Pizza

    Posted by Smash Studios on 05/30/2008

    Forget the other review...great place!

    Huge portions, friendly and courteous staff. Great pizza ...great pasta, too! Forget what our other guy said...these guys have worked very hard to make our experience with them top-notch, and they've surpassed all expectations. We HIGHLY recommend this place!

  • Fat Sal's Pizza

    Posted by SMASH STUDIOS on 08/27/2007

    The Worst Ever

    We are removing this resturaunt from our menu book. We used to suggest to our clients this was the place to order from. Then tonight we were sent the worst stuff ever. The chicken Parm might have been returned by another customer and reheated. When we called to complain we were hung up on. We will never order from here again and neither will any one having a session here.

  • Fat Sal's Pizza

    Posted by New Yorker Hotel Visitor on 10/22/2006


    Had food delivered to The New Yorker Hotel. It was SUPER FAST delivery. All food was excellent - pizza, cheese fries, garlic knots. Yummy. This would be the only pizza place I come back to in New York for my next visit. Excellent! It was delivered so I didn't get to experience that atmosphere, but they were super friendly on the phone & in person. Thank you!

© 2015 GrubHub, Inc. All rights reserved.