Welcome to MenuPages - Please Select a city:


  • $$$
  • Italian
  • 334 Lexington Ave, New York 10016 40.749731 -73.977608
  • (At 39th St)
  • click map to interact
  • (212) 883-9555
  • 0

User Ratings (Based on 25 reviews)

avg-come back to15
Food 4 Value 4
Service 3 Atmosphere 3_5

Other Restaurant Info

(212) 883-9555
Visa, MC, AmEx, Disc, DC, Carte Blanche
Mon-Fri: 12pm-10pm Sat-Sun: 5pm-10pm
Dinner, Lunch
Accepts Credit Cards, Business Dining, Catering, Delivery, Good for Groups, Online Reservations, Pre/Post Theater, Private Parties, Prix Fix Menus, Take Out
Min Delivery:

User Reviews

  • Fagiolini

    Posted by Bob on 2011-12-22


    This was the second time I ate at the Fagiolini on 40th Street. The first time I ate with a colleaque for lunch and I liked the restaurant. Last saturday night I ate dinner here with a friend. I made a reservation about 45 minutes prior. When we got to th

  • Fagiolini

    Posted by Lisa on 2011-11-21

    Not recommended

    Called here as it was highly praised by a guest in our hotel and boy was I sorry I did. Asked for a pizza without cheese and was told it could not be done, I reckon this just highlights how unfresh they must be or that they are not homemade. Ended up wit

  • Fagiolini

    Posted by FMM on 2011-02-14

    Great experience

    We were here for the time tonight and were pleasantly surprised. My partner had Pollo All'ortolano and she found the sauce to be light and flavorful and the chicken to be very tasty. I had spaghetti and meatballs and the sauce was also mild and tasty an

  • Fagiolini

    Posted by rosebud on 2010-04-08

    Crowded but Great Food

    I go to Fagiolini's when I'm in the neighborhood, about once a month. The tables downstairs are quite close together so it feels like you're having dinner with everyone. (I don't know what the upstairs is like.) They could use another waitperson. BUT.

  • Fagiolini

    Posted by nycfoodie on 2009-12-01

    Not recommended

    The food here was not good at all. The house "salad" was some iceburg lettuce, a piece of tomato that was not ripe and some shredded carrots drowing in vinegar and a drop of oil. Appetizer of minestrone soup was fair at best. Their so called special, pe

  • Fagiolini

    Posted by KAM on 2009-06-12

    Great local spot!

    I've gone to this place for years and never had a bad time. It atmosphere is quiet and pleasant. I find the staff helpful and they do not rush anyone. A bonus is the excellent value, including the wines! There are very few places you are able to find

  • Fagiolini

    Posted by Viv on 2009-03-04

    Great food!

    The food is delicious! Service was so/so, but I'd go back for the pasta and the ricotta cheesecake!

  • Fagiolini

    Posted by coconyc on 2009-02-02

    great food, nice atmosphere and yes one bad waiter

    While I agree with some that service can be inconsistent, I used to live in the neighborhood for 20 yrs and always came here for great food and a very pleasant time with family or friends. A couple of times I have had the waiter whose attitude leaves som

© 2018 Grubhub, Inc. All rights reserved.