Exclusive Pizza

Agree with previous reviews- owner makes best pizza. He's tall, caucasian- ish? (sorry don't know his name), with a close cut. Only have really enjoyed grabbing a regular slice or regular cheese pie. Once toppings are added something goes wronger; not bad but not as good. Cheap, fast, good slices!

I have eaten at Exclusives ever since i was a kid. Their prices are cheap and even though the atmosphere isnt perfect, I still love this place.

Although some will say George's pizza is the best? i will respectively have to disagree, although i will say George's is a local institution here in the heights BUT exclusive is the best pizza. delicious sauce and big slices for just two bucks can't be beat! the sandwiches are are also pretty good, especially for the prices. although i have to warn you guys... there seems to be hired hands now making the pizzas & sandwiches there and when those guys are preparing the food it's hit or miss..so eater beware. if you see the gruf main guy there (sorry don't know the dude's name) then you know you will be getting the best pizza in the hood. i guess he has hired these new hands and i guess he needed the help :{ i try to buy when he's there..those other workers can really fu#@! your pizza up at times...it's just not the same. anyways great pizza for great prices can't be beat.

I'm a life-long NY'er and have dealt with all types of restaurant experiences. Unfortunately my most disappointing has come at Exclusive Pizza. I've given them multiple chances to do right but they are just a bad business. From taking up to an hour and half for delivery, and the pizza looking like somebody took the pie and swirled it all together, to forgetting about deliveries, to eventually ordering over the phone and picking up and they still got the order wrong. Guy actually tried to charge me $11 for 2 slices of pizza with two toppings.

I usually get my pizza from George's but from time to time i enjoy a thinner slice so i thought i would try out Exclusive. overall, not bad. sauce is a little sweet and I appreciated that it was a little thinner than Georges' pizza. Exclusive is more of a quintessential NY slice. maybe not the best but for a $10.00 medium its great! atmosphere is a typical pizzeria and service speedy and all business. I don't think you would regret grabbing a slice/pizza from this place!

I was so excited when I found this place in the hood. All the other pizza joints around here are terrible and this place was a breath of fresh air. But lately the pizzas are old, reheated and dry, tasteless boards of wood. The burgers taste like they were fresh in 1960 and the delivery service has gone from so-so to bad. I hope their customers go elsewhere for a while so they figure out they need to bring the A game.

The meatball parm hero is delicious and cheap for what you get, the pizza is fantastic and the servers...exist. But hey, if you want them to kiss your behind go somewhere that requires a dinner jacket. As far as pizzerias go, this place is phenomenal.