Welcome to MenuPages - Please Select a city:

El Maguey (CLOSED)

Restaurant & Lounge
  • $$
    RatingAvg. Dinner Entrée
    $$$$$Greater than $25
    $$$$$18.01 - $25
    $$$$12.01 - $18
    $$$7.01 - $12
    $Less than $7
  • Mexican
  • 3473 Broadway, New York NY10031 40.8244158 -73.9520806
  • (Btwn 141st & 142nd St)
  • click map to interact
  • (212) 234-6965
  • 0

Desayunos $6.50

Breakfast Served With Rice, Beans And Soft Tortillas. Extra Charge After 2pm.

Huevos Con Salchicha eggs & sausage.   
Huevos Rancheros western eggs.   
Huevos Con Cecina eggs with salted beef.   
Huevos A La Mexicana eggs mexican-style.   
Huevos Con Chorizo eggs with sausage.   
Huevos En Salsa Verde Or Roja eggs with green or red sauce.   
Huevos Revueltos Con Nopales scrambled eggs with cactus.   
Huevos Con Tocino eggs with bacon.   
Huevos Con Jamón eggs with ham.   



Ensalada De Camarones shrimp.   10.50
Seafood Salad mixed seafood.   11.00
Caesar Con Pollo chicken.   8.50
Ensalada De Aguacate avocado.   7.50
Regular Ensalada    4.50
Ensalada De Nopales Con Espinacas tender baby cactus salad, served over a bed of baby spinach with onions, tomatoes, cilantro, red radishes and tossed with house dressing.   7.50

Quesadillas A Mano

Homemade Fresh Corn Tortilla Folded Over Melted Oaxaca Cheese. Served With Lettuce, Pico De Gallo, Guacamole, Sour Cream And Cotija Mexican Cheese.

Pollo Quesadilla chicken.   5.50
Carnitas Quesadilla roasted marinated pork.   5.50
Bistec Quesadilla beef steak.   5.50
Vegetales Quesadilla vegetables.   6.00
Queso Oaxaca Quesadilla mexican cheese.   6.50
Chorizo Quesadilla mexican sausage.   7.00
Camarones Quesadilla shrimp.   7.95
Flor De Calabaza Quesadilla pumpkin flowers.   7.00
Cecina Quesadilla salted beef.   7.50


Corn Flour Patties Topped With Beans, Red Sauce, Avocado, Sour Cream And Mexican Cotija Cheese.

Chorizo Sope sausage.   4.00
Pastor Sope marinated spicy pork.   3.50
Pollo Sope grilled chicken.   3.50
Carne Asada Sope grilled beef.   3.50
Regular Sope plain.  (3pcs) 6.00

Nachos Rancheros

Chips With Beans, Oaxaca Cheese, Lettuce, Tomatoes, Onions, Cilantro, Sour Cream, Jalapeños And Grated Cheese.

Nachos Regulares plain nachos. sm 6.50 lg 7.50
Nachos Rancheros chicken, beef steak and pork. sm 7.50 lg 8.50
Nachos Vegetarianos mixed vegetables. sm 7.50 lg 8.50
Nachos De Camarones Y Vegetales nachos with shrimp and vegetables.   13.00


Delicious From The Grill. With Onions, Cilantro, Radish And Slice Of Lemon.

Carne Asada Tacos broiled beef.  2.50 (3) 7.00
Pollo Asado Tacos broiled chicken.  2.50 (3) 7.00
Carnitas Tacos fried pork.  2.50 (3) 7.00
Carne Enchilada Tacos spicy pork.  2.50 (3) 7.00
Al Pastor Tacos gyro-style.  3.00 (3) 7.50
Chorizo Tacos sausage.  3.00 (3) 7.50
Cecina Tacos salted beef.  3.00 (3) 7.50
Lengua Al Vapor Tacos steamed tongue.  3.00 (3) 7.50
Vegetariano Tacos vegetarian.  3.00 (3) 7.50


Deep-Fried Corn Tortilla Topped With Beans, Lettuce, Tomato, Sour Cream And The Meat Of Your Choice. Order Of Three.

Tostadas De Regulares regular.   5.00
Tostadas De Lengua tongue.   9.95
Tostadas De Carne Asada broiled beef.   9.95
Tostadas De Cecina salted beef.   9.95
Tostadas De Pollo chicken.   9.95
Tostadas De Carnitas fried pork.   9.95
Tostadas Al Pastor gyro.   9.95
Tostadas De Chorizo sausage.   9.95
Individual Tostada   ea 3.50


Deep-Fried Corn Tortilla Shaped As Sandol Soles With Beans, Lettuce, Tomatoes, Onions, Avocado, Sour Cream And Cotija Cheese.

Pollo Huarache chicken.   6.50
Bistec Huarache beef steak.   6.50
Chorizo Huarache mexican sausage.   6.50
Nopales Y Queso Huarache cactus and cheese.   8.45
Tinga Huarache pollo.   7.50
Vegetariano Huarache mixed vegetables.   8.00

Flautas $7.50

Crispy Tortilla Rolls With Your Choice Of Filling. Served With Cotija Cheese, Sour Cream, Rice And Beans.

Chicken Flauta    
Cheese Flauta    


Include The Ingredients Of Your Choice. Served With Rice, Beans And Flour Tortillas.

Pollo Alambre chicken.   9.95
Bistec Alambre beef.   9.95
Chorizo Alambre sausage.   9.95
Al Pastor Alambre roasted pork.   10.00


Homemade Thick Corn Tortilla Topped With Red Sauce, Onions, Oaxaca Cheese, Avocado And The Ingredient Of Your Choice.

Regular Chalupa plain.   2.00
Pollo Chalupa chicken.   3.00
Bistec Chalupa beef.   3.00
Picadillo Chalupa ground beef.   3.00
Chorizo Chalupa mexican sausage.   3.00
Espinaca Chalupa spinach.   3.00
Camaron Chalupa shrimp.   4.95
Salmon Chalupa salmon.   4.95

Burrito Gigante

Flour Tortilla Wrap With Rice, Beans, Lettuce, Tomatoes, Onions, Guacamole, Sour Cream And Oaxaca Cheese.

Carne Asada Burrito broiled beef.   8.50
Burrito De Cecina salted beef.   8.50
Pollo Asado Burrito broiled chicken.   8.50
Vegetariano Burrito vegetarian.   8.50
Carnitas Burrito fried pork.   8.50
Burrito Al Pastor gyro-style.   8.50
Chorizo Burrito sausage.   8.50
Camaron Burrito shrimp.   10.95


Made With Grilled Green Peppers, Onions And Tomatoes. Served With Rice, Beans And Flour Tortillas.

Bistec Fajitas    9.50
Pollo Fajitas chicken.   9.50
Vegetales Fajitas mixed vegetables.   9.00
Camarones Fajitas shrimp.   13.00
Mixta Fajitas    15.00


Mexican Sandwiches Made On A Roll Of Bolillo Bread And Prepared Mexican-Style With Refried Beans, Tomatoes, Fresh Avocado, Onions, Jalapeños, Lettuce And Cheese.

Milanesa De Pollo Torta breaded chicken.   5.95
Milanesa De Res Torta breaded beef.   5.95
Salchicha Con Huevo Torta eggs and sausage.   5.95
Jamon Y Queso Torta ham and cheese.   5.95
Chorizo Con Huevo Torta sausage with eggs.   7.50
Quesillo Torta oaxaca cheese.   7.50
Carne Asada Torta broiled beef.   7.50
Pechuga Asada Torta grilled chicken breast.   6.50
Cecina Torta salted beef.   8.50
Carne Enchilada Torta spicy pork.   7.50
Cubana Torta cuban.   8.00


Traditional Tortilla And Green Tomatillo Salsa Or Red Guajillo Salsa Bedding. Served With Onions, Sour Cream And Cotija Cheese.

Chilaquile Regulares plain.   8.00
Chilaquile Con Carne Asada grilled beef.   11.00
Chilaquile Cecina salted beef.   12.50
Chilaquile Cecina Con Dos Huevos salty beef with two eggs.   14.50
Chilaquile Huevos Estrellados sunny side up eggs.   10.00
Chilaquile Pollo Asado broiled chicken.   11.00


Chicken Mexican Dishes Served With Rice, Beans And Homemade Tortillas.

Mole Poblano chicken with mole sauce.   9.90
Milanesa De Pollo breaded chicken breast.   11.00
Pechuga De Pollo A La Mexicana sautéed chicken breast with tomato, onion and jalapeño.   11.00
Pechuga De Pollo Asada Con Pico De Gallo grilled chicken breast with pico de gallo sauce.   11.00
Pechuga De Pollo Con Nopal Asado Y Cebollitas Cambray chicken breast with grilled cactus and cambray onions.   11.00
Pollo En Mole Verde chicken with green sauce made with jalapeños, tomatoes, cilantro, onions and spices.   9.90
Pollo En Pipian chicken with pumpkin seeds sauce with touch of cilantro and herbs.   9.90
Pollo En Chipotle chicken with chipotle sauce made with tomato, onions and chipotle peppers.   9.90
Enchiladas Poblanas De Pollo O Queso tortillas filled with chicken or cheese in mole sauce topped with lettuce, radish, avocado and cotija cheese.   10.70
Enchiladas De Mole Verde De Pollo, Carne O Queso tortillas filled with the ingredients of your choice and green sauce with lettuce, tomato, onions, cotija cheese and sour cream.   10.70


Meat Mexican Dishes Served With Rice, Beans And Homemade Tortillas.

Steak Norteño new york grilled steak.   15.00
Steak Ranchero new york grilled steak.   15.00
Steak A La Tampiqueña new york grilled steak.   15.00
Bistec A La Mexicana sautéed beef with tomatoes, onions, cilantro and jalapeños.   10.70
Cecina Con Nopales Asados Y Cebollitas Cambray salted beef.   14.00
Carne Enchilada lightly spicy pork.   13.00
Cecina Encebollada salted beef with onions.   14.00
Cecina En Salsa Verde O Roja salted beef in green or red sauce.   14.00
Chuletas Rancheras grilled pork chops with jalapeños and onions.   13.00
Steak Con Pure De Papa grilled new york steak with mashed potatoes and spinach.   15.00


Seafood Mexican Dishes

Camarones Enchipotlados spicy shrimp.   13.50
Camarones Al Mojo De Ajo shrimp in garlic sauce.   13.50
Camarones A La Mexicana shrimp mexican-style.   13.50
Camarones A La Veracruzana shrimp veracruz-style.   13.50
Filete De Salmon Asado salmon filet.   14.00
Camarones A La Diabla sautéed tiger shrimp with chipotle sauce.   13.50
Mojarra Al Mojo De Ajo porgie sautéed in garlic sauce, served with rice, beans, salad and soft tortillas.   14.00

Continental Dishes

Camarones Apanados breaded shrimp with rice, fried sweet plantain, russian salad and french fries.   12.00
Camarones Al Ajillo shrimp in garlic sauce, rice, salad and french fries.   13.00
Chuletas A La Parrilla grilled pork chops, rice, sweet plantain, french fries and salad.   13.00
Arroz Con Camarones fried rice with onions, green peppers, cilantro and shrimp.   12.00
Arroz Con Pollo fried rice with onions, green peppers, cilantro and chicken.   9.00
Arroz Marinero mixed seafood and rice.   13.00
Chaulafán typical ecuadorian rice mixed with shrimp, meat, onions, green peppers and cilantro.   11.00
Pollo Al Estilo El Maguey chicken with mushrooms, white wine and cream milk, served with mixed vegetables and potatoes.   11.00
Pechuga A La Parrilla grilled chicken cutlet with rice, fried and salad.   11.00
Carne Asada Con Menestra Y Tostones grilled beef with rice, fried green plantain and beans.   10.00
Carne Apanada Con Arroz breaded beef served with rice, russian salad and avocado.   10.00
Churrasco grilled beef served with rice, two fried eggs, avocado, french fries and salad.   11.00
Combinacion Maguey grilled beef, pork chops, egg, rice, beans, sweet plantain and avocado.   12.00


Coctel De Camarones shrimp cocktail.   12.00
Ceviche De Camarones shrimp ceviche.   12.00
Salchipapas fried hot dog with french fries and pico de gallo.   5.00
Picada Mixta chicken, pork, beef and sausage.   15.00
Tamales mexican tamal.   3.00

Side Orders

Chips & Salsa chips and sauce.   3.50
Aguacate avocado slice.   3.50
Tostones green plantains.   3.00
Maduro sweet plantains.   3.00
Papas Fritas french fries.   3.00
Arroz rice.   2.75
Frijoles beans.   3.00
Guacamole mashed avocado.   5.00
Guacamole Con Chips with chips.   7.50
Pico De Gallo    3.50
Orden De Tortillas    3.00

Desserts $4

Flan De Caramelo    
Pastel Tres Leches    

Licuados $4


Mamey Licuado    
Mango Licuado    
Melon Licuado    
Papaya Licuado    
Maracuya Licuado    
Fresa Licuado    
Mora Licuado    
Guanabana Licuado    


Café coffee.   1.50
Hot Chocolate    1.50
Tea    1.00
Espresso    1.00
Cappuccino    2.50

Juices & Sodas

Jugo De Naranja orange juice.   4.00
Jugo De Combinado mixed.   4.00
Horchata    4.00
Tamarindo    4.00
Soda De Lata coke, diet coke, pepsi, sprite, ginger ale   2.00
Soda Mexicana limon, toronja, mandarina, fruit punch, tamarindo, manzana, uva   2.50
Boing    2.50
El Maguey
3473 Broadway
Btwn 141st & 142nd St
(212) 234-6965
or (212) 234-6974
© 2015 GrubHub, Inc. All rights reserved.