Welcome to MenuPages - Please Select a city:

Eisenberg's Sandwich Shop

  • RatingAvg. Dinner Entrée
    $$$$$Greater than $25
    $$$$$18.01 - $25
    $$$$12.01 - $18
    $$$7.01 - $12
    $Less than $7
  • Diners & Coffee Shops, Sandwiches
  • 174 5th Ave, New York NY10010 40.741188 -73.99026
  • (Btwn 22nd & 23rd St)
  • click map to interact
  • (917) 765-9300
  • 0

User Ratings (Based on 60 reviews)

Food 4.0 Value 4.0
Service 3.8 Atmosphere 3.9

Other Restaurant Info

(917) 765-9300
Place Order:
Order From Eisenberg's Sandwich Shop for delivery & takeout
Free Delivery Take Out Major Credit Cards Corporate Accounts
Mon-Fri: 6:30am-8pm Sat: 9am-6pm Sun: 9am-5pm
Breakfast, Lunch
Accepts Credit Cards, Cheap Eats, Delivery, Online Ordering, Take Out, Wheelchair Accessible
Min Delivery:

User Reviews

  • Eisenberg's Sandwich Shop

    Posted by Ange@Roadrunner on 07/27/2006


    I used to order from ANOTHER place on 23rd which has decent food..but the service there is terrible. I must have gotten french toast 5 or 6 times without butter when I specifically told them to throw tons of butter in the bag& does extra cheese mean no cheese? Anyway, one day my coworkers were ordering from Eisenbergs and I figured why not try something new..that was 2 months ago and ive been a customer ever since. I LOVE the food & speedy delivery and the prices are great for Manhattan! 5 all the way!!!

  • Eisenberg's Sandwich Shop

    Posted by waterlilly212 on 06/20/2006

    Excellent first impression!

    I decided to give eisenberg a try today. I noticed they serve cold borscht which is VERY refreshing during hot summer months (if it's made right). Mind you my grandmother made the best borscht on earth, so my standard is HIGH. Eisen's borscht is damn good! They get my slavic stamp of approval. Service was friendly and fast, and I loved the "old school" atmosphere. I will definately be back to try their chopped liver & pastrami!

  • Eisenberg's Sandwich Shop

    Posted by tunesnyc on 05/26/2006

    Old school love

    The best pastrami sandwich I've ever had. God bless this place. May it stay open forever. It is a link to an era I was born too late to see. But walking into this place, settling into the counter with a newspaper, and eating diner food they way it was meant to be served, I feel closer to the glory days of NYC than at any other moment in my ten years living here. I suspect the ghost of E.B. White keeps a table in the back.

  • Eisenberg's Sandwich Shop

    Posted by foodhunter on 03/13/2006

    New - The Eisen-Burger!

    Oh my - been coming here for years - now in addition to the most delicious chopped liver (a new recipe) and yummy shrinp salad (also a new recipe - i ask alot of questions!) - they have added BURGERS! They are delicious - made to order (the fries are great too) - the best burger for taste and price in the neighborhood. Now how will I choose what to have for lunch?

  • Eisenberg's Sandwich Shop

    Posted by Jill on 02/03/2006

    Great little find

    My Boss recommended this place to us, and it was pretty great. Gruff, yet friendly cooks right at the counter chatted with us and gave us free hot chocolate and coffee. Cheap, good, and great for lunch!

  • Eisenberg's Sandwich Shop

    Posted by foodluvngal on 12/17/2005

    My favorite neighborhood favorite!

    Eisenberg's has been a long-time favorite for me and many of my friends. The food is fresh, the service terrific and now, under new management, it's even better! The new owner warm and friendly, and is really cleaning the place up -- while still maintaining Eisenberg's "old-time" feel. The sandwiches are even more generous, the meats of higher quality and don't get me started on the CHOPPED LIVER! It's fresh every day and OUT OF THIS WORLD! The eggs are fresh and deliciously pan-fried, and not thrown onto the same griddle where the bacon or onions or who knows what else has just been cooked. And, in keeping with tradition, Eisenberg's has that old-time "just-tell-the-cashier-what-you-had" honor method of payment! I love not having to ask for a check! Where else in NYC do you get to do that? I read the review of the guy below and admittedly, when Eisenberg's is busy, which is typical during lunch, delivery may take a little while. But, give yourself some extra time, 'cause IT'S WORTH THE WAIT! If you're discovering Eisenberg's for the first time, you'll immediately feel just as comfortable as us regulars who have been going there for years. (At breakfast a few weeks ago, I overheard one customer refer to Eisenberg's as being like "Cheers" - with eggs!) Do yourself a favor. Get to Eisenberg's as soon as you can. I know it'll be your newest favorite joint INSTANTLY!

  • Eisenberg's Sandwich Shop

    Posted by from Baltimore on 05/24/2005

    Saturday morning breakfast

    I brought my friends/colleagues -- an Englishman and a Texan -- with me for breakfast Saturday morning at Eisenberg's. I wanted my friends to go to a traditional diner or breakfast counter, the kind I enjoyed when I lived in Manhattan as a student. Though that day the Flatiron building was in shrouds, and Eisenberg's had run out of lox, we thoroughly enjoyed our bialys (halved, perfectly toasted and buttered) and eggs at the counter. The staff were patient, welcoming and kind. Perhaps they could afford to be so, since there were only a few of us at the counter, and it was early. I just wish I ordered an egg cream!

© 2015 GrubHub, Inc. All rights reserved.