Hold down Control (PC) or Command (Mac) key + mouseclick to select more than one option
Upper West Side >
Ed's Chowder House
Posted by nypsych on 11/05/2014
The chowder is ersatz, despite the name! It is a hot creamy sauce with little pieces of clam thrown in. No clam taste! Not cooked with clams! So much so that it made me wonder if the clams were canned - all uniform and small pieces and tasteless. A decent (expensive) seafood restaurant but not special.
Posted by Ronnid on 01/10/2014
A chowder house should make good chowder- right? Have had better from a can....Both clam chowders were watered down and under seasoned with nothing much in them. The New England- had such a strong pork/bacon there was no taste of clams at all- and we only saw one clam in the cup....the Manhattan tasted like Campbells canned veg soup- again no clams- The mushroom /leek was yummy- but that did not save the meal. The crab cake- was mostly bread crumbs and deep fried- I just drowned it in the sauce that tasted jarred- The green beans were split open like the ones you get frozen in a bag- overcooked and limp The french fries were good- For $350- I would expect something to be worth eating. The atmosphere was nice- the waiter was strange- the drinks were light- You can get equally good fries at McDonalds- save your money- go someplace else
Posted by Fran Walters on 05/26/2013
I stopped in for a quick meal. Ordered the mushroom chowders and warm beet salad. Both dishes were fine, but your wait staff disappeared.....not a good impression.
Posted by Anonymous on 01/27/2013
I wasn't to sure about this place because of the other reviews. This place is amazing. The hostess greet you and make you feel comfortable. They ask you about your day while walking you to your table, I mean how many restaurants really care about your day. But anyways the wait staff is amazing, Management is very accommodating and very funny. What restaurant do you go to in NYC and actually lay eyes on the Manager ? Food is amazing very detailed, cooked well. I recommend the surf and turf, The lobster roll not to much mayo buttery it's just right this place is A M A Z I N G. I come here often and it is worth every penny. People will always have something negative to say don't believe it till you have witnessed it your self. Go and visit this place I LOVE IT.
Posted by Megan on 10/08/2012
I had mixed feelings going into this place because of some of these reviews, but my family and I had an amazing time. The food is excellent and staff very nice. Service was attentive and they made us feel at home. Will absolutely go back! The fluke is delicious
Posted by SS on 06/08/2012
I am surprised by some of the negative comments here. We dined here two days ago for lunch after a NY Phil rehearsal. Food was wonderful, wait staff so helpful, and the ambiance was great. Lobster roll was perfect! Will definitely go back!
Posted by Rob360 on 05/27/2012
After they seated us it took 20 minutes for our waitress to take our order! She had such an attitude it was crazy. The food was great, but it was impossible to flag anyone down to get extra butter, water etc. and of course our waitress was never to be seen until it came time to pay. Will not be going back due to the service.