Welcome to MenuPages - Please Select a city:

Eatery NYC

  • RatingAvg. Dinner Entrée
    $$$$$Greater than $25
    $$$$$18.01 - $25
    $$$$12.01 - $18
    $$$7.01 - $12
    $Less than $7
  • American (New), Eclectic & International
  • 798 9th Ave, NEW YORK NY10019 40.765261 -73.987512
  • (At 53rd St)
  • click map to interact
  • (212) 765-7080
  • 0

User Ratings (Based on 124 reviews)

Food 3.7 Value 3.4
Service 3.4 Atmosphere 3.6

Other Restaurant Info

(212) 765-7080
(212) 765-3269
Place Order:
Order From Eatery for delivery & takeout
AmEx, MC, Visa, Disc
Weekday Brunch Mon-Fri: 11am-4pm Dinner Sun-Wed: 5pm-11pm Thu-Sat: 5pm-12am Weekend Brunch Sat-Sun: 9am-3:45pm
Lunch, Dinner, Brunch
Group Dining, Open Late, Outdoor Dining, Prix Fixe, Pre/Post Theater, Gluten Free Items, Delivery, Online Reservations, Online Ordering, Wheelchair Friendly, Accepts Credit Cards, Take Out, Catering
Min Delivery:
Delivery Area:
36th to 72nd St; 5th Ave to Hudson River Park

User Reviews

  • Eatery NYC

    Posted by Anonymous on 03/21/2008

    Worth The Wait

    Came here for Sunday (3/16) brunch wife my wife and my sister who came in from Long Island. We waited almost 45 minutes as the place was packed to the hilt which gave me ample time to observe. All the food brought out to the tables looked delicious and not much was left on each plate, if any. The entire staff could not have been more friendly and hustled non stop. When we were seated the hostess had already let our waiter know we had a 3:00 show to make and he was very attentive to our time limit. Our meals were well worth the wait. My stuffed french toast was off the hook! The Eatery is not big on atmosphere but is a must stop for locals and tourists alike.

  • Eatery NYC

    Posted by KW on 02/27/2008

    Overall good

    We started with the sweet potato and corn empanadas. They were OK, cooked nicely, with a mild flavor, I expected more but couldn't complain much. My GF had the meatloaf. Eatery's meatloaf was nothing special at all. The meat was OK, average homemade tasting meatloaf, the potatos actually tasted like mix mashed and she said the broccoli was overcooked. Overall she ate it, but didn't really enjoy it. I on the other hand had the Tender beef medallions with speghetti squash and truffle mashed. The whole dish was great, and even though it was a fair sized portion I liked it so much I could have ate another portion. This dish alone is why I've given the food rating a 4 otherwise it would have been a 3. Dessert was banana spring rolls they were good and enjoyable, not amazing but good. So the food is overall good, but I wouldn't recommend the meatloaf. The place itself has a nice neighborhood trendy feel to it, both decor and crowd. The tables are a little too close together which I didn't care for, but a lot of small places do this to maximize seating which I can understand to a degree. Service was only a little above average simply because they were well informed about the dishes. Overall, I would go again, although I would find it hard not to order the same dish because mine was so good. For the price, (no alcohol) tax and tip included for 2 was $75 so not terrible at all. I say give it a try and if you don't like it try it once more and you still won't have lost much.

  • Eatery NYC

    Posted by bdaygurl08 on 02/25/2008

    Good Food- Mediocre Service

    Went there on my b-day, 2/23. There were 5 of us and we made a reservation for 9pm but did not get seated until 9:45. We were told by the host that we would be seated in a booth next to the window but instead they stuck us in the back of the restaurant by the restrooms and had given our original table to another party who came in after us. The food is okay. I ordered the sirloin burger with sweet potato fries. The burger melted in my mouth but the fries were a little over cooked. The waiter we had placed the wrong order for one of my friends and we sent it back and by the time his dish was ready the rest of us had already finished our meal. I would probably go back to give them another chance.

  • Eatery NYC

    Posted by Repeat Diner on 01/21/2008

    You Can't Eat Attitude

    This place is Number One on my list of never again. The food wasn't awful. But the service was not good. Our server made it clear he had better things to do than wait on us, and was cold to the point of being rude. The food tasted alright, although it wasn't anything special and certainly wasn't memorable. We were offered no refills on beverages, and they practically yanked forks out of our mouths in an effort to clear the plates, shove us out the door and turn the table. There are a hundred good restaurants on 9th Avenue in Midtown. My suggestion is go to another one. ANY other one.

  • Eatery NYC

    Posted by Anonymous on 01/21/2008

    Eat Here!

    What a fun restaurant! Loved the modern decor and the cute waiters - they really knock themselves out providing great service. I had their Mac 'n Cheese and it was soooo good.

  • Eatery NYC

    Posted by anon14 on 01/07/2008

    Great anytime

    I've eaten here a handful of times, and I'm always happy with the food and drinks. But I just had to write to give a shout-out to the staff. They're always as accommodating as they can be (given the space limitations), and I've gotten a free drink more than once because of prolonged waits. Now THAT's how to keep your customers coming back!

  • Eatery NYC

    Posted by Mboy2 on 12/10/2007

    Real Good!

    Simple and great. I love the Vermont Cheddar Meatloaf. They have awesome martinis too. Four of us ate and I thought the bill would be so much more. Definitley go here if your from the area.

© 2015 GrubHub, Inc. All rights reserved.