Hold down Control (PC) or Command (Mac) key + mouseclick to select more than one option
Midtown West >
Daisy May's BBQ USA
Posted by foodiegoodie on 08/03/2008
I love the food here from the pulled pork to the Oklahoma Jumbo ribs you can't go wrong. The sides are to die for- dirty rice, mashed sweet potatoes are all stellar. The problem is the price- the price is just out of whack by a couple of dollars per entree. I would eat here probably 2-3 times a month if they lowered the prices by a few dollars....I am instead on the once every 2-3 months daisy may plan do to the prohibitively high pricing...
Posted by NoodleBob on 07/04/2008
What was once a reliably decent BBQ joint that was good value for money and appealing to locals, has turned into an overpriced, sub-par tourist trap for those with decrepit palates. I stopped there for lunch recently and spent a whopping $21 (up from $17) on the jumbo beef rib with beans and mash as sides. The beef was tough and chewy and lacking in flavour. The sides tasted like they had been left overs from several days earlier. In the past we'd make a pilgrimage from Murray Hill as a treat, but feel less inclined to now that the standards have lowered.
Posted by Anonymous on 06/17/2008
Certainly worth the trip over. The BBQ was great. It was a little hard to find a seat, but that is usually a sign of a good place. Definitely would go back here.
Posted by LUKE on 03/25/2008
Great food all around, but a little pricey for BBQ. The service is excellent
Posted by BVfoodie on 12/18/2007
This was one of the first places to appear during New York City's BBQ Renaissance and was a true "find" during the first few years of its existence. My friends and I would travel across from Midtown just to get the walk-in specials--the food was that good and the walk-in special pricing made it great value! However, after the walk-in specials pricing was raised last year, I just can't bring myself to do that walk anymore.
Posted by Anonymous on 12/01/2007
This BBQ joint on 11th avenue is equipped with a smoker and a genuine southern BBQ shack feel to it. HOWEVER, the prices are insane. A sandwich is nearly $10 without a side and drink. The prices are sky high and it's more of a tourist trap than a good old New York type of place. What is New York turning into? Disneyland?
Posted by Fooder on 10/31/2007
Only have had delivery. Give yourself alot of time as it takes awhile. Call early and schedule your delivery. Beef rib rocks! Beer can chicken is a bit dry. Beans are good and creamy corn is good. Sticky rib are good.