Welcome to MenuPages - Please Select a city:

Croton Reservoir Tavern

  • $$$$
    RatingAvg. Dinner Entrée
    $$$$$Greater than $25
    $$$$$18.01 - $25
    $$$$12.01 - $18
    $$$7.01 - $12
    $Less than $7
  • American (Traditional), Bar Food
  • 108 W 40th St, New York NY10018 40.7537945 -73.985665
  • (Btwn Broadway & 6th Ave)
  • click map to interact
  • (212) 997-6835
  • 0

Lunch

Cold

Fresh Mozzarella & Tomato beefsteak tomatoes, fresh mozzarella, basil oil, and balsamic reduction   11.00
House Made Hummus roasted garlic hummus with fresh tomato, cucumber slices and warmed pita bread   11.00
Beet And Goat Cheese braised beets, baby arugula, crispy goat cheese, pistachios, sherry vinaigrette and pomegranate reduction   11.00
Nori Seared Rare Tuna pan seared rare, sliced over a bed of seaweed and carrot salad, garnished with miso-vinaigrette, wasabi peas and cilantro oil   16.00

Hot

Lobster Bisque made daily from fresh lobsters with a touch of cream, lobster meat, puff pastry, and chives   10.00
Shrimp And Crispy Grits blackened shrimp, stewed tomatoes, okra, jalapeno, scallions and crispy polenta fries   15.00
Maryland Crab Cake jumbo lump crab mixed with old bay and scallions, pan seared, served with roasted corn salsa, lobster sauce, crispy leeks and cilantro oil   15.00
Spinach, Artichoke And Corn Dip fresh spinach, artichoke hearts and corn mixed with four cheeses served hot with tortilla chips   12.00

Salads

Traditional Cobb mixed greens, tomato, avocado, bacon, egg, bleu cheese crumbles and fresh grilled diced chicken with a side of bleu cheese dressing   16.00
Kale Salad fresh kale, quinoa, cherry tomatoes, bell peppers, mandarin oranges, roasted sunflower seeds tossed with sherry vinaigrette   14.00
add grilled chicken   4.00
add grilled shrimp, add skirt steak   7.00
add seared tuna   9.00
Arugula, Asian Pear & Bleu Cheese pear, shaved fennel, bleu cheese crumbles, toasted pumpkin seeds and walnuts with a side of citrus vinaigrette   14.00
add grilled chicken   4.00
add grilled shrimp, add grilled skirt steak   7.00
add seared tuna   9.00
Classic Caesar romaine lettuce with herb croutons tossed in our caesar dressing and topped with shredded parmesan cheese   12.00
add grilled chicken   4.00
add grilled shrimp, add grilled skirt steak   7.00
add seared tuna   9.00

Sandwiches

Served With A Fresh Cabbage Slaw And House Made Chips. Add $3 For Regular Or Sweet Potato Fries, Add $2 To Include A Small Portion Of Mixed Greens.

Roasted Turkey Breast Wrap peppered bacon, fresh avocado, swiss cheese, lettuce, tomato with dijon aioli in a wheat wrap   15.00
Spicy Grilled Chicken Wrap grilled chicken, celery, carrots, onion, mixed greens, buffalo sauce and bleu cheese dressing in a red pepper wrap   14.00
Chicken Salad Sandwich grilled chicken breast, dijon, mayo, grapes, fresh tarragon, served in a brioche hot dog bun and topped with roasted walnuts   14.00
Skirt Steak Sandwich marinated then grilled topped with arugula and garlic aioli on a rustic hero   19.00
Pulled Pork beer braised pork, carolina barbeque sauce, cheddar cheese, pickled okra, green cabbage and scallions on a seeded brioche bun   17.00
Frangelico Lobster Roll fresh lobster salad with celery mixed lightly with frangelico liqueur served on a brioche hot dog bun   21.00
Maryland Crab Cake Sandwich jumbo lump crab, pan seared golden brown and served with tomato, arugula, scallions with lime aioli on a sesame seed brioche bun   17.00
French Dip roast beef and melted mozzarella in a toasted baguette served with au jus   17.00
White Bean And Quinoa Burger house made with white beans, red quinoa, parmesan cheese, roasted garlic served with shredded kale, tomato and cranberry aioli on a sesame seed brioche bun   17.00
Char Grilled Black Angus Burger custom 8oz beef topped with cheddar cheese and smoked bacon served on a sesame seed brioche bun   15.00

Entrees

Grilled Salmon fresh salmon with roasted vegetable israeli couscous and a cucumber, tomato and spinach salad tossed in basil vinaigrette   26.00
Seared Tuna yellowfin tuna seared rare with nori seasoning, stir-fried oyster mushrooms, snow peas, red peppers, soy glaze, wasabi pea mashed potatoes, roasted seaweed and chili oil   29.00
Chicken Paillard grilled chicken breast with a salad of baby arugula, mixed greens, fennel, fresh cherries, fresh herbs, toasted almonds and white balsamic vinaigrette drizzled with balsamic reduction   19.00
Roasted Chicken Pot Pie classic roasted chicken veloute sauce with a touch of cream tossed with mushrooms, seasonal vegetables and herbs topped with puff pastry   20.00
Skirt Steak Chimichurri grilled 10oz marinated angus skirt steak served with roasted corn mashed potatoes, seasonal vegetables and chimichurri sauce   27.00
Italian Sausage Linguine sweet italian sausage, roasted peppers and onions, fresh herbs, and linguine tossed in our hearty ragout sauce topped with parmesan cheese and garlic bread   19.00
Spring Vegetable Rigatoni sautéed mushrooms, asparagus, roasted red peppers, and spring peas tossed in a light cream pistachio pesto with fresh herbs and topped with parmesan cheese   19.00
add grilled chicken   4.00
Filet Mignon Tagliatelle pan seared filet mignon tips, asparagus, roasted mushrooms, charred cherry tomatoes and fresh herbs tossed with tagliatelle pasta in a light horseradish cream sauce topped with parmesan cheese   22.00

 

Dinner

Beginnings - Cold

Fresh Mozzarella & Beefsteak Tomato basil oil, balsamic reduction   11.00
House Made Roasted Hummus garlic, tomato, cucumber, warmed pita bread   11.00
Arugula, Asian Pear And Bleu Cheese Salad shaved fennel, bleu cheese crumbles, toasted pumpkin seeds, walnuts, citrus vinaigrette   10.00
Green Kale & Quinoa Salad cherry tomatoes, bell peppers, mandarin oranges, roasted sunflower seeds, sherry vinaigrette   14.00
Red & Gold Beets And Crispy Goat Cheese braised, baby arugula, pistachios, sherry vinaigrette, pomegranate reduction   11.00

Beginnings - Hot

Lobster Bisque housemade daily. fresh lobster, touch of cream, garnished with a puff pastry and chives   10.00
Blackened Shrimp And Crispy Grits stewed tomatoes, okra, jalapeno, scallions, crispy polenta fries   15.00
Nori Seared Rare Yellowfin Tuna seaweed and carrot salad, miso vinaigrette, wasabi peas, cilantro oil   16.00
Maryland Jumbo Lump Crab Cake pan seared, old bay, scallions, roasted corn salsa, lobster sauce, crispy leeks, cilantro oil   15.00
Spinach Artichoke And Corn Dip four cheeses served hot, tortilla chips   12.00

Entrees

Grilled Salmon roasted vegetable israeli couscous, cucumber, tomato and spinach salad, basil vinaigrette   26.00
Seared Rare Yellowfin Tuna nori seasoning, stir-fried oyster mushrooms, snow peas, red peppers, soy glaze, wasabi pea mashed potatoes, roasted seaweed, chili oil   29.00
Grilled Chicken Breast Paillard salad of baby arugula, mixed greens, tomatoes, fennel, fresh cherries, fresh herbs, toasted almonds, white balsamic vinaigrette, balsamic reduction   19.00
Prime Angus Sirloin Steak 10oz, truffle mushroom mashed potatoes, seasonal vegetables, port wine reduction   28.00
Grilled Skirt Steak Chimichurri 10oz, marinated, roasted corn mashed potatoes, seasonal vegetables, chimichurri sauce   27.00
Croton Avocado Angus Burger 8oz chopped beef, spicy, grilled, avocado, bacon, havarti cheese, scallions, tomato, chipotle aioli, sesame seed brioche bun served with polenta fries   20.00
Roasted Chicken Pot Pie classic roasted veloute sauce,touch of cream, mushrooms, seasonal vegetables, herbs. served in a skillet topped with puff pastry   20.00
Sweet Italian Sausage Linguine roasted peppers and onions, fresh herbs, hearty ragout sauce, parmesan cheese and served with garlic bread   19.00
Filet Mignon Tagliatelle pan seared tips, asparagus, roasted mushrooms, fresh herbs, horseradish cream sauce topped with parmesan cheese   22.00
Spring Vegetable Rigatoni sautéed mushrooms, asparagus, roasted red peppers, spring peas, fresh herbs, light cream pistachio pesto, topped with parmesan cheese   19.00
add grilled chicken   4.00

 

Brunch

Brunch Served Between Saturday And Sunday: 11am-4pm

Yogurt Parfait yogurt sweetened with honey and served with granola, fresh strawberries and blueberries   8.00
Blueberry French Toast thick slice brioche bread battered with cinnamon, eggs and cream. served with a warm blueberry compote and topped with vanilla whipped cream   14.00
Croton Madame two slices of toasted brioche topped with gruyere cheese and smoked ham, served with two eggs sunny side and béchamel sauce   15.00
Crab And Arugula Frittata three egg baked frittata, filled with colossal lump crab meat, arugula, mushrooms, parmesan cheese and garnished with tomatoes   18.00
Overstuffed Crt Omelet three egg omelet filled with chefs choice of fresh meats and vegetables ask server for details   
Steak And Egg Ranchero sautéed steak, avocado, tomatoes, red bell peppers, red onion and cilantro, sandwiched between two corn tortillas with 2 eggs any style, topped with cheddar and pepper jack cheese   14.00
Breakfast Burger grilled 8oz angus patty topped with sharp cheddar cheese, peppered bacon and a fried egg. served with spicy onion marmalade on a seeded challah bun   15.00
Italian Eggs Benedict two eggs poached on top of italian sausage, sautéed spinach and garlic bread with tomato hollandaise and herbs   16.00
Country Skillet sautéed chorizo and smoked ham, onions, peppers, scallion, cajun seasoning, two eggs sunny side and seasoned home fries served in a hot iron skillet   14.00

Brunch Specials

Entrée And 2 Drinks    24.00
Entrée & Unlimited Drinks    35.00
Drink Options: Mimosa, Bellini, Melontini & Sangria 1/2 Price Bottles Of Veuve Clicquot & Stellina Di Notte Proseccos

Salads

House Made Hummus served with fresh tomato, cucumber and warmed pita bread   11.00
Fresh Mozzarella & Tomato balsamic vinaigrette, basil oil, balsamic reduction   11.00
Traditional Cobb mixed greens, tomato, avocado, bacon, egg, blue cheese crumbles and diced chicken with a side of blue cheese dressing   15.00
Arugula, Pear And Bleu Cheese pear, shaved fennel, bleu cheese crumbles, toasted pumpkin seeds and walnuts tossed with citrus vinaigrette   14.00
Classic Caesar romaine lettuce with parmesan cheese and garlic croutons tossed in our caesar dressing   12.00
Add Grilled Chicken $4, Grilled Skirt Steak $7, Grilled Shrimp $7, Seared Tuna $9

Sandwiches

Served With A Fresh Cabbage Slaw And House Made Chips. Add $3 For Regular Or Sweet Potato Fries Or Add $2 To Include A Small Portion Of Mixed Greens.

Maryland Crab Cake Sandwich jumbo lump crab, pan seared golden brown and served with tomato, arugula and scallions on a sesame seed brioche bun   17.00
Frangelico Lobster Roll fresh lobster salad mixed with frangelico liqueur served on a brioche hot dog bun. exculded from brunch specials.   21.00
Grilled Black Bean Veggie Burger house made with black beans, red onion, bell pepper, chili spices and roasted garlic served with cilantro sour cream, lettuce and tomato on sesame seeded brioche   14.00
Spicy Grilled Chicken Wrap grilled chicken, celery, carrots, onion, mixed greens, buffalo hot sauce and bleu cheese dressing in a red pepper wrap   13.00
Skirt Steak Sandwich with arugula and a garlic aioli on a rustic hero. exculded from brunch specials.   19.00

Sides

Bacon    4.00
Sausage    5.00
Home Fries    5.00
Smoked Ham    5.00
Fresh Fruit Bowl    8.00

 

3 Course Pre-Theatre Prix Fixe $34.95

Available Between 4-7pm. Includes 1 Glass Of Our House Red Or White Wine.

No Substitutions Please.

Beginning

Classic Caesar romaine, herb croutons, shredded parmesan cheese, tossed in our caesar dressing   
Fresh Mozzarella & Beefsteak Tomato basil oil, balsamic reduction   
Soup Of The Day    

Main

Grilled Chicken Breast Paillard salad of baby arugula, mixed greens, tomatoes, fennel, fresh cherries, fresh herbs, toasted almonds, white balsamic vinaigrette, balsamic reduction   
Spring Vegetable Rigatoni sautéed mushrooms, asparagus, roasted red peppers, spring peas, fresh herbs, light cream pistachio pesto, topped with parmesan cheese   
Grilled Skirt Steak Chimichurri 10oz, marinated, roasted corn mashed potatoes, seasonal vegetables, chimichurri sauce   

Dessert

Homemade NY Style Cheesecake with fresh strawberry coulis   
Assorted Ice Creams    
Regular/ Decaf Coffee And Tea Included

 

Dessert

Brownie Sundae house made brownie served with vanilla ice cream topped with whipped cream, walnuts fresh strawberries, drizzled with chocolate sauce   
Tropical Fruit Rice Pudding coconut milk, sushi rice, mango, pineapple, strawberry, green tea cream and toasted coconut   
Caramel Apple Pie hot apple pie served with a vanilla ice cream   
New York Cheesecake served with fresh strawberry coulis   
Plate Of House Made Cookies baked fresh in house daily   

Bar Menu

Small Plates

Polenta Fries crispy polenta fries, parmesan cheese, truffle oil, fresh herbs   9.00
Spinach, Artichoke And Corn Dip artichoke hearts, spinach, roasted corn, garlic, parmesan, pepper jack cheddar, tortilla chips   12.00
Hummus roasted garlic hummus, tomato, cucumbers, warm pita bread   11.00
House Made Potato Chips made fresh daily in our kitchen   3.50
Beet And Goat Cheese braised beets, baby arugula, crispy goat cheese, pistachios, sherry vinaigrette and pomegranate reduction   11.00
Maryland Crab Cake jumbo lump crab, scallions, old bay, roasted corn salsa, lobster sauce, crispy leeks   15.00
Nori Seared Tuna seared tuna rare, seaweed salad, miso vinaigrette, carrots, wasabi peas, cilantro oil   16.00
Basket Of Fries regular shoestring or sweet potato fries   6.00
add truffle oil and parmesan   3.00
Appetizer Tower hummus, buffalo fingers, cheeseburger sliders  (3) 26.00
Grilled Flatbread Pizzas margherita   11.00
italian sausage, pesto and peppers   13.00
Crt Nachos beef and bean chili, pepper jack cheddar cheese, pico de gallo, guacamole, sour cream, cilantro   9.00
Buffalo Fingers fried chicken breast tossed in buffalo sauce, served with bleu cheese dressing   12.00
Chicken Wings tossed with buffalo sauce, carolina style barbeque, or asian ginger sauce, served with bleu cheese dressing   12.00
Mac And 3 Cheese cavatappi pasta tossed with creamy bechamel sauce, fontina, gruyere and parmesan cheeses, topped with toasted bread crumbs and chives   9.00

Sliders

Minimum Order Of 3. Add $3 For Regular Or Sweet Potato Fries

Classic Cheeseburger cheddar cheese, lettuce, tomato, onion, pickle  ea 4.00
Buffalo Chicken pulled chicken in buffalo sauce, celery, carrot, blue cheese crumble  ea 4.00
Sausage & Peppers sweet italian sausage, roasted onions and peppers, cherry pepper mustard  ea 4.00
Beer Braised Pork carolina style barbeque pulled pork with apple-jalapeno slaw  ea 4.00
White Bean Burger house made, white beans, red quinoa, parmesan cheese, roasted garlic served with shredded kale, tomato and cranberry aioli  ea 4.00
Maryland Crab Cake jumbo lump, old bay, tomato, crispy leeks, lime aioli  ea 4.00
Filet Mignon pan seared medium rare, arugula, tomato, red onion, horseradish aioli  ea 4.00
Lobster Roll Sliders 3 minis of fresh lobster salad mixed with frangelico liquer   18.00

Sandwichs & Wraps

Served With Fresh Cabbage Slaw & Housemade Potato Chips Add $3 For Regular Or Sweet Potato Fries

Skirt Steak Sandwich marinated then grilled, topped with arugula and garlic aioli on a rustic hero   19.00
Char-Grilled Black Angus Burger custom beef topped with cheddar cheese and smoked peppered bacon served on a sesame seed brioche bun   15.00
Spicy Grilled Chicken Wrap grilled chicken, celery, carrots, red onion, mixed greens, buffalo sauce, bleu cheese dressing in a red pepper wrap   14.00

 

Martini

Lychee grey goose la poire, lychee, lemon, lime & simple   
French 75 ombay, lemon & prosecco   
Corpse Reviver bombay, lillet, cointreau & lemon   
The Bergeron bulleit rye, cognac, carpano antica, benedictine, angostura & peychaud's   

Cocktails

Daiquiri nut allergy. bacardi light, cherry heering, lime   
Machu Pisco pisco, st. germain, lime, lemon, egg white & absinthe   
Gold Rush buffalo trace, honey syrup & lemon   
May Daisy hennessy, green chartreuse & lemon   
Cuarenta Y Tres dickel rye, licor 43, lemon & egg white   
Singapore Sling nut allergy. bombay saphire, pineapple, cherry heering, cointreau, benedictine, lime & angostura   
I Don't Drink Whiskey rye, lemon, mint & sugar   
Moscow Mule crystal head vodka, ginger beer, lemon & simple   

Margaritas

Yucatan Meets Maui tequila, habanero & hibiscus   
Mother Earth tequila, beet & lime   

Draught Beer

American Pale Ale bronx pale ale   8.00
American Lager brooklyn lager   7.50
sam adams lager   8.00
shiner bock   8.00
Belgian Amber ommegang rare vos   9.00
Belgian Pale Ale leffe blonde   9.00
duvel single   9.00
Belgian Tripel chimay tripel   9.00
Belgian White blue moon   8.00
English Pale Ale bass   8.00
European Pale Lager stella artois   8.00
Pilsner coney island pilsner   8.00
IPL coney island ipl   8.00
IPA goose island ipa   9.00
rebel ipa   9.00
Stout guinness   8.00
Cider angry orchard   8.00
Seasonal sam adams summer   8.00

Bottled Beer

American Lager

Brooklyn Lager    
Budweiser    
Bud Light    
Coors Light    

 

American Amber Ale peak fall summit ale   
American Pale Ale peak pale   
Belgian Ale chimay white, red, blue   
English Lager samuel smith organic   
English Brown Ale samuel smith nut brown   
Fruit Beers ithaca apricot wheat   
magic hat no. 9   
IPA sierra nevada   
southampton   
Pilsner peak organic freshcut   
Stout left hand milk stout nitro   
samuel smith oatmeal   

Belgian Style Pale Ale

Brooklyn Local #1    
Duvel    
Goose Island Matilda    
Goose Island Sophie    

Cider

Angry Orchard Crisp Apple    
Angry Orchard Green Apple    
Magners    
Mckenzies Green Apple    
Mckenzies Black Cherry    
Mckenzies Lazy Lemon    

Imported Lager

Amstel Light    
Corona    
Heineken    
Heineken Light    

 

Wine By The Glass

White

Sauvignon Blanc new harbor   10.00
Chardonnay wild horse   12.00
a by acacia   10.00
Fume Blanc ferrari carano   11.00
Pinot Grigio mezzacorona   10.00
Riesling sterling vineyards   10.00
Rosé goats de roam   10.00

Red

Cabernet Sauvignon simi   13.00
mondavi private selection   11.00
Chianti ruffino superiore   10.00
Malbec terrazas   12.00
Merlot blackstone   10.00
Pinot Noir gavilan   13.00
coppola   11.00
Tempranillo campo viejo   10.00
Shiraz red diamond   10.00
Zinfandel rosenblum   10.00

Champagne & Sparkling

Prosecco stellina di notte   13.00
Veuve Clicquot    18.00

 

Croton Reservoir Tavern
108 W 40th St
Btwn Broadway & 6th Ave
(212) 997-6835
Advertising
© 2002-2014 Slick City Media, Inc. All Rights Reserved. MenuPages® is a trademark of Slick City Media, Inc. Disclaimer