
Hold down Control (PC) or Command (Mac) key + mouseclick to select more than one option
| Rating | Avg. Dinner Entrée |
|---|---|
| $$$$$ | Greater than $25 |
| $$$$ | $18.01 - $25 |
| $$$ | $12.01 - $18 |
| $$ | $7.01 - $12 |
| $ | Less than $7 |
Reviews from nymag.com
| Food | ![]() |
Value | ![]() |
|---|---|---|---|
| Service | ![]() |
Atmosphere | ![]() |
Posted by Anonymous on 11/29/2011
Poor customer service
I order soup to go here from time but no more. I ordered soup recently and the man behind the counter yelled for someone in the back to get it while he stood around and did nothing. The man in the back poured my soup into the container and placed it next to him while he cleaned a pot. My soup just sat there next to him. When he was done cleaning his pot, he placed it on the counter in front of me. Instead of writing up my ticket so I could pay for the soup (you pay with a receipt at the register in the front), the man behind the counter glances at the soup, walks past it into the kitchen and back, then gets on the phone. My soup sat on the counter with the receipt book right next to it for 5-6 minutes. 3 employees walked by and no one wrote up my ticket. I was the only customer at the counter! I finally asked one of the employees if they could write up the ticket so I can pay for the soup and the man on the phone says to that employee, "I guess she can't wait." Wait for what? Him to get off the phone? For soup to get cold? How rude are these people. I asked him "what do I need to wait for"? He gave me a dirty look and continued his phone call. He could have written up my ticket in a matter of 2 seconds. This place lost a customer today.
Posted by anonymous on 11/13/2011
OK, but order carefully
This is a decent 24hr diner that does a few things well and a few things badly. First off, I hate the burgers. They're huge, dense, undersalted, and usually overcooked. Go to Veselka for a better burger at 4am. However, do order their soups or their milkshakes, they're all good. All the triple decker sandwiches are decent. The spinach pie and meat loaf are also good. The fresh-roasted turkey is usually pretty dry. The cole slaw is really good. Skip the steak fries and get the curly fries. Skip the mozzarella sticks, they're dense and from the freezer. Skip the pastrami.
Posted by Lenore on 08/31/2011
Cozy is wonderful!
I had a great experience as soon as I walked through the door--I was greeted almost like I was a member of a very warm and caring family. The menu is huge with many dietary options. I would not call the food "cheap eats" but the quality and quantity are excellent. The wait staff is very friendy and accomodating. Viva Cozy! (I'll fill in an appropriate Greek term later). ps. They are there for your comfort and dining pleasure 24/7.
Posted by Anonymous on 06/13/2010
Very Good But
Very Good but never order BLT this is very important, you do not order BLT
Posted by Bert on 05/05/2010
Mediocre
Went for lunch. Ordered a tuna melt sandwich and fries. Tuna melt had no appeal. The cook didn't make the effort to spread the tuna salad evenly, or up to the edges of the toast, so that it looked like ugly globs, and at times I was eating pieces of toast with no tuna or cheese upon them. This was something I would expect to be served in my friend's kitchen. Fries were alright. Soda was not filled up to the top of the glass. Otherwise, waiter was attentive. Overpriced.
Posted by PhoBeau on 02/22/2010
High Priced Diner Food
The food is above average for diner fare and the prices are way above average. You can drop $20 for lunch and leave wondering if you should have had a V8.
Posted by jsm on 12/29/2009
always a hit
This place is always a hit. We found it over a year ago and were pleased from the beginning. We bring out of towners here and they always love it. We've ordered anything from burgers and fries, to tuna fish, to omelettes to french toast, to chili, etc. etc. We've never been dissatisfied. The servers are cranky, but hilarious and it makes it a fun atmosphere. I'd recommend it to anyone. It's a good place.