MenuPages

We were in New York for just five days and ate twice at this restaurant. Both times the food was excellent and the service superb.

One of those lousy, rainy days in Manhattan, but Connolloy's brightened the mood. We all had wraps which were excellently, fairly priced, and served as advertised. The menu is varied with a lot of old favorites. People we spoke with said the chicked pot pie was "marvelous". If you're a french fry connoisseur theirs are light, not greasy, and lightly crusted, not too salty. Worth a visit. We were at the one on 45th St. before a show. We'll go back again.

My mother, her friend and her friend's 18 year old daughter came to town, and my boyfriend and I wanted to take them somewhere with a diverse menu, good prices and great atmosphere in Times Square. We were not disappointed! There was no wait to get seated for our party of 5, and the service was good. Each of us ordered something very different, and everyone raved about how good the food was. My mother said they served the best sheppard's pie she had ever had (and she is not easy to please!)

A group of us travel to New York from Ireland every year and our first stop for food and drinks is Connolly's. The staff are so friendly , all in all the place is brilliant. We love it and we will be back there for Easter 2006... The Shepards pie is delicious!

My friend and I were looking for a place to eat after seeing a movie. Since a lot of streets seem rather dead around 10pm (?!), and our first choice was closed, we went here randomly. It was pretty decent, considering it was randomly picked! But I think that's more a testament to this great city (and its food) than to our luck. I ordered a wrap and my friend ordered a veggie burger, which was HUGE. The wrap tasted pretty good, and I was satisfied. The prices were a little steep on the other menu items (hey we were just looking for a quick bite to eat). The atmosphere was pretty good--they divide the bar side from the restaurant side pretty well, since there was a VERY lively bar crowd when we were there, but we hardly noticed as it was pretty quiet on our side. I would come here again, maybe for a real dinner.

My wife and I have had two dinners and the food and service were great. It's a relaxed atmosphere with great food at a reasonable price.

After sitting and waiting for a salad, a wrap and a burger for 45 min, we decided to leave. The service is terrible, and when you say something, they stare at you with blank faces. Definitely do not go for lunch if you only have an hour, youll never end up eating!