Hold down Control (PC) or Command (Mac) key + mouseclick to select more than one option
Midtown East >
Diners & Coffee Shops >
Posted by Anonymous on 09/18/2013
Incredibly noisy, run down and dark. Prices too high for what it is. Johns around the corner at 44th & 2nd far superior. REAL eggs benedict at brunch, including coffee/tea, juice or fruit cup and potatoes - not fake with pieces of bacon under the eggs like here. Take a lesson Ira and check out the competition.
Posted by anonymous on 09/22/2012
I had my breakfast here quite a few times in the last week. Everytime it was great, service varied a little, but only from good to very good. As for prices, initally they seemed a little high, but after comparing with a few other diners the pricing is similar but the food is much better. Highly recommended for a great breakfast/ brunch.
Posted by camc on 01/26/2010
I'm surprised to see so many negative reviews - I've never had bad service or bad food at the Comfort Diner. I admit they can be a bit slow with delivery, but I usually eat in. I've never gone for lunch, but it's great for meeting friends for a casual supper after work.
Posted by eastside girl on 12/15/2009
I dont understand how this place is so busy at lunch when the food was not good. The price is high for the quality and taste of food, some bars have better food.
Posted by mary soilex on 09/08/2009
A royal disapointment. It promises much, delivers a lot less, The food is moderately mediocre on THEIR BEST DAY.. the eggs had a bacon taste..like cooked in bacon fat, and the toast was soggy....my cofee was bitter, luke warm, and the waiter had an unpleasant and even hostiel attitude...I felt insulted on top of everything, i went there twice...but honey, ONECE WAS ENUF, NO THANKS!!
Posted by Foodie Patootie on 08/10/2009
Some of our food was cold, some too salty, some not salty enough. All of it was mediocre and one item downright disgusting. But our biggest complaint was that the poorly designed interior made it impossible for my companions and I to hear one another. Even when the place was empty. Even if the food had been better, we won't be going back, I'm sorry to say.
Posted by Diner Guy on 07/20/2009
The food here is not bad (although a bit pricey for what you get). But the service is simply terrible. The waiter we had the last 3 times we went there is just a jerk, and the manager could care less. Taking my business somewhere else.