Hold down Control (PC) or Command (Mac) key + mouseclick to select more than one option
Upper West Side >
Diners & Coffee Shops >
Posted by SomeGuy on 05/10/2010
Burger and Fries, and Chicken Fingers with Fries..... No drinks... $30 before tip ?? Completely not worth it. Unless you like sub-par diner food, and getting ripped off at the same time, there are plenty of places with better quality for the same price, all over NYC.
Posted by maxNYC on 03/27/2010
The food quality and atmosphere have declined over the years, but the food is still average to good diner food. The staff can be rude at times, particularly when you call for delivery...I've had them hang up on me in the past when they had trouble understanding me, but if I were working there I wouldn't be to friendly either. However, for a late meal with friends after a night of drinking or for fast/free delivery, they are the best.
Posted by tony on 03/08/2010
service is great food is yummy take out is fast and i should say this place rocks
Posted by Clare on 02/09/2010
Came here on the last day of our New York holiday as we were staying close by. It was fantastic! Wish we'd gone everyday. Huge portions, keen service, great value.
Posted by Anon on 12/04/2009
To say that that City Diner's food is excellent would be misleading. As a diner their food is what is to be expected or better, and usually good. City is the best diner in the area. Staff are sometimes a little abrupt & curt, but hey - don't tip if the service is BAD!
Posted by JFintheCity on 11/18/2009
Good food, good value, fun (if slightly worn) art deco interior. The service is quick if occasionally spotty. But overall, exactly what I expect and hope for from a neighborhood diner. Glad it's so close to my apt...during stress times it becomes my second kitchen!
Posted by 14A on 10/22/2009
I've been ordering once or twice a day from City Diner since my oldest daughter was born 22 years ago. When I call, the people who answer the phone recognize my voice and say "14A?" The deliveries come quickly and the food is hot and excellent. My kids love Haagen Dazs ice cream, which is what CD serves, so sometimes we call just to order that. I love their coffee, and when I'm away it's one of the NYC things I miss the most. Best items for take out are anything breakfast, soups, burgers, ravioli, tom turkey dinner; the grilled fish can be surprisingly good. Now that my kids are older they like to hang out at CD in the wee hours of the morning (It's open 24/7). It's a safe, well lit place to be at those hours, and the staff is kind to the kids, so I'm delighted they have this option. CD is a friendly community center for the Upper West Side. I never fail to see friends and neighbors there, and know we all benefit from this wonderful place.