Hold down Control (PC) or Command (Mac) key + mouseclick to select more than one option
Upper West Side >
Diners & Coffee Shops >
Posted by kb on 08/22/2014
I agree with the previous reviewers who have noted a recent decline in the quality of the food (fries was the example with which I heartily agree), as well as an unexpected and unprecedented rudeness in the tone of the person who took my order this Friday night. So sad. Used to be a great place with reliable food and efficient service.
Posted by hgc on 03/09/2014
First they replaced the steak fries with tasteless fries. Now the Heinz ketchup is out, and the generic ketchup is in. The shakes also have reduced ice cream content.
Posted by service on 02/14/2014
Asked them to deliver to Mount Sinai hospital and did not know where it was..... so they dont know much about their surroundings since it employees over 30,000 people.....next after going to pic up the food, service poor, food worse, going back there again.....NEVER...
Posted by aRT on 06/14/2013
This used to be the best diner on the upper West side, but it's changed in the last two years. They forgot how to cook.Try Café 82 or the New Wave diner.
Posted by anonymous on 04/02/2013
very rude!! not friendly or helpful, avoid delivery from these people!!
Posted by Anonymous on 10/31/2012
I was born and raised in NYC and can say that this is one of the best diners I've been too. The prices are standard Manhattan prices (pretty high, but oh well), and the food is great. Really nice salads, burgers, eggs, etc. The service has always been solid, and it's always been a really nice, really New York experience. My husband is a vegan and really likes their veggie burger. He usually hates diner veggie burgers, so that says a lot. Yummy!
Posted by Anonmous on 08/18/2012
I have been coming to City Diner for about 2 years now. The service is friendly and well, the food is always excellent. With this economy the pricing is good.