Hold down Control (PC) or Command (Mac) key + mouseclick to select more than one option
Posted by Noodlie on 05/02/2007
Boy was this place a disappointment. I should've listened to my co-workers who insisted that Red Lobster is even better than City Crab. The entire meal was mediocre at best. Calamari was so-so. My crab legs were just okay, definitely have had better. Roasted potatoes came out warm and quickly turned cold. My boyfriend ordered the $32 seafood "platter" which consisted of three shrimp, one crab cake and two scallops....all of which weren't even tasty! How is this place still up and running?! Do yourself a favor and go someplace else if you're craving seafood. Ick.
Posted by Anonymous on 01/02/2007
Went here for a last meal before some friends went back to CA. It wasn't crowded and the setting was very nice. I enjoyed my dungeonous crab and potatoes. Everyone liked their drinks as well but did not like how slow the food came out. In all faireness we were pretty hungry before we got there. Best seafood I've had so far in NY. I think you could probably get better value somewhere else though.
Posted by Bon Vivant on 10/18/2006
Went here with the family for lunch, and the food was mediocre at best. My grilled swordfish sandwich was so dry and devoid of flavor that I had to send it back. The hamburger our daughter had was burned and tasteless. The lobster roll DW had was ok, so not all was lost. Our waiter forgot to bring our wine. In overall felt more like a diner than a restaurant. Perhaps the dinner quality is better judging from prior reviews.
Posted by Anonymous on 08/13/2006
City crab is my favorite seafood restaurant by far. if you're looking for lobster, look no further! for a place in manhattan, and a great location, the prices are pretty reasonable. i tend to stick with the special that includes lobster, clams, oysters, corn, and potatoes ($19.95 right now) and thats a great deal! their food is even cheaper than red lobster's (in times SQ) and more fresh and just really good. i would recommend trying it at least once if you love seafood.
Posted by Restaurant Lover on 05/05/2006
Last week my boyfriend and I checked out this place. I had been wanting to go here for such a long time. Our server was very friendly. When we ordered the wine we had Cabernet in mind. The server made his recommendation : the most expensive one. We had a min. to decide on one and picked a med. priced one. We joke that I bet they "wouldn't" have it but would have the most expensive one. We were right - how conveinient. Besides that we had a great meal. My alaskan king crab legs were to die for. I still dream about them. The place could use a renovation - for the food they are serving it should look a little classier (esp. w/the prices). I would def. love to go back.
Posted by happy on 04/26/2006
City crab was one of the best dining experiences in a seafood restaurant, the food is always fresh and quality is great. slightly on the pricey side but you get what you pay for! I try to go as often as my wallet will let me.
Posted by NYC on 04/09/2006
City Crab consistently serves great, fresh seafood. A little on the pricey side, so I don't frequent it, but it's worth it for a night out when you want a guaranteed good meal. No problems with the service; in fact, my waiter was extraordinarily nice. Usually no wait, so there's no need to call ahead. They have two floors and an incredibly large amount of tables, and they're usually 80% full. Most people I know love it there, so it's not unpopular. I'd recommend it as a good city standard.