Welcome to MenuPages - Please Select a city:

Cielo at the Mayfair (Formerly Caffe Cielo)

  • $$$
  • Italian
  • 242 W 49th St, New York 10019 40.761259 -73.985834
  • (Btwn Broadway & 8th Ave)
  • click map to interact
  • (212) 489-8600
  • 0

User Ratings (Based on 35 reviews)

avg-come back to15
Food 4 Value 4
Service 4 Atmosphere 4

Other Restaurant Info

(212) 489-8600
Visa, MC, AmEx, Disc
Mon-Fri: 12pm-12am Sat-Sun: 11am-12am
Dinner, Lunch
Accepts Credit Cards, Gluten-Free, Live Music, Online Ordering, Pre/Post Theater, Take Out, Wheelchair Accessible

User Reviews

  • Cielo at the Mayfair (Formerly Caffe Cielo)

    Posted by Racer J on 2014-08-18

    Quality for the price

    Found this place just before heading home. Nice little Italian place. Not the number one ranked Italian Resturant in the area, but you can't beat it for the price. Food was very good, setting was quaint. Staff was friendly and pretty on the spot. Will go

  • Cielo at the Mayfair (Formerly Caffe Cielo)

    Posted by Mike V on 2014-06-30

    Food is traditional Italian and best in Times Square

    The food and service is excellent and hard to compare against any other venue in the neighborhood.

  • Cielo at the Mayfair (Formerly Caffe Cielo)

    Posted by Tucker F on 2013-05-24

    Delightful and delicious

    Home-made pasta, delicious sauces, good service, friendly all around: I will return. I recommend this charming place and I will be returning. See you there!

  • Cielo at the Mayfair (Formerly Caffe Cielo)

    Posted by EPR on 2012-04-19

    Nice Average Italian Restaurant

    My friend and I had dinner at this place before heading to the theater and we had no complaint. Food was good, service and ambience were ok. It's not a top restaurant but not bad either.

  • Cielo at the Mayfair (Formerly Caffe Cielo)

    Posted by Hawkeye on 2012-04-05

    Mediocre at best

    Took our son and his wife based on recommendations here and were very disappointed. Service was indifferent and food was very generic. Won't be going back.

  • Cielo at the Mayfair (Formerly Caffe Cielo)

    Posted by Buddy on 2011-12-27

    Frequent diners

    My wife and I live in the neighborhood and often dine here. We have always been extemely pleased with the food and the service. The fried calamari is among the "best in town" and the other fish entrees have never disappointed, especially the sole.

  • Cielo at the Mayfair (Formerly Caffe Cielo)

    Posted by hot lips on 2009-11-02

    agitating experience

    Chose restaurant based on on line reviews and proximity to theater I was going to. I eat out very very often but was disappointed from the beginning of the meal when the bread arrived. This is an Italian restaurant in New York City with many many bakeries

  • Cielo at the Mayfair (Formerly Caffe Cielo)

    Posted by MR. ANDERSON on 2009-04-27

    Excellent Dining Experience

    I often use the reviews from previous patrons as part of my selection process, and it really paid off this time. “What a great group of people at this Restaurant”. Making reservations was painless and they graciously thanked us ahead of time. Heavy

© 2015 GrubHub, Inc. All rights reserved.