MenuPages

Cheesy Pizza offered one of my favorite slices of pizza as a kid growing up. It was always too greasy, but nonetheless delicious -- the perfect cheese to tomato ratio. Also as a kid 99 cent slices were the best. I ordered a pie today and was thoroughly disappointed -- I am assuming there was a change in ownership and/or pizza making technique. The pizza tasted terrible and seemed to be very flimsy (lack of cheese/sauce/crust. The one redeeming quality of the pizza itself was that the crust was quite good.

I have been here several times. I have no idea why I still chose to return except that I lived a couple of blocks away. Establishment is dirty, staff do not pay attention to orders and the pizza is below average. Something is not right when the slice is extremely heavy. They also use very cheap ingredients and you can tell from the first bite.

Why is a large pie with pepperoni and a pepsi $25 and change? WHY?

I'm not one to expect much so when I'm disappointed there is something wrong. One question, who doesn't give sauce with a calzone? That among the fact that the food is way overpriced and the service is not good. The guy on the phone just hung up on me before I even finished my order. He had my phone number by then and didn't call back, but apparently my order was still in when I called back, it was just incomplete. Terrible. This is the third time and the last time I will be disappointed by this establishment.

Atmosphere and service is no worse than any of the city's 8 million Ray's or Famiglia's. And I know I'm in the minority here but I actually really like their pizza! The plain, pepperoni, and white slices/pies are what I always order. I'll happily walk a few blocks out of my way... past half a dozen of their competitors... to grab a slice or two and a root beer. :-) Certainly not exceptional... but very solid!

All good pizza should have some grease, but the slice I had contained a pool of grease in the center. Plus, I don't know where they get the counter help, but I had to tell the guy three times it was for here & not to go.

The base is way too greasy, and the cheese, their pride and joy, is of a low grade. The reviewers who write that their product is not consistent are 100% right flavor and thickness changes from pie to pie.