Hold down Control (PC) or Command (Mac) key + mouseclick to select more than one option
Posted by Kev on 07/25/2010
The tagliatelle was excellent, but the gnocchi was bland and the penne was soso. The fried cheese appetizer was interesting though. Would come again to try the pizza. Service was fine, though the place is quite small and cramped.
Posted by Katie on 06/28/2010
I just read all these poor reviews and can't believe it. Its not the most convenient place. Tight quarters, kind of loud and there's usually a wait. But its worth the wait. Proprietor can always be found on premises and he is always very accommodating. Food is always fresh and very tasty. For the price its a no brainer. My husband is Italian. We eat here all the time. One of his faves.
Posted by anonymous on 04/11/2010
I keep reading and hearing amazing things about Celeste. I am beyond confused by the hype. The food was beyond bland. It had zero flavor and to say I was disappointed doesn't even cut it. There are so many delicious italian restaurants in NYC i can't understand why anyone would come here. You can have a better italian dinner experience with a box of barilla pasta and a jar of sauce.
Posted by A true Italian on 03/25/2010
The food is fine. It is the arrogance of the owner I can do without. And what's up with the "we cannot sit you until all parties have arrived"? C'mon! I walked out...my time is more valuable than just sitting around waiting for a table glued to the one next to it. Too full of themselves!
Posted by Anonymous on 02/26/2010
This place needs new waiters ASAP.
Posted by boxter on 02/17/2010
I've lived in NY my entire life and have dined at some of the city's finest restaurants and Celeste offers nothing more than a cheap imitation of authentic Italian food. The food is mediocre , the atmosphere poor and the service worse. With so many other fine restaurants in the city to choose from there's no need to bother with this one.
Posted by JT on 02/07/2010
Mediocre food at okay prices with downright rude service.