Hold down Control (PC) or Command (Mac) key + mouseclick to select more than one option
Posted by Anonymous on 06/05/2010
As far as basic American Southern Italian food goes, you can't get any better than Cataldo's. Delicious, fresh, good portions and good prices. The chicken parm is probably the best around, and the place is run by a really nice family. Whether it's pizza or an entree, everything is top notch. I'm here once a week at least.
Posted by Jenna on 06/03/2010
We were surprised to get such good pizza at this casual neighborhood place, but it has become one of our weekly staples. Try the Pugliese!
Posted by Brianna on 02/27/2010
So I live on nostrand and that I one block out of the delivery range. I gave them an address a block closer and walked to pick it up-- petty but my friend raved it was worth it. We got chicken parmesean sandwiches and a margherita pizza. it was a good deal for nine bucks. the sandwich was a little soggy but it's delivery. all in all I was satisfied.
Posted by Carmonaville on 01/04/2010
This place boasts great home cooking and is quite affordable. The person that said it tasted like tin confused me... Always good on a consistent basis. Would recommend this to anyone looking for the warmth of good Brooklyn Italian food.
Posted by Italian in BK on 10/17/2009
We keep going back. The food reminds me of mom's homemade cooking. It's fresh, tasty and the portions make you smile. It's not like restaurants where you need to search for the food. I really enjoy the atmosphere of this place. They are super sweet and very welcoming. I really have nothing to complain about. The selections are great and if there is something special you want all you have to do ask they will make it if they can with a smile. The pizza is amazing too. The smell alone will have you drooling. You really need to go there and see for yourself. I hope you enjoy as we always do. Cataldo's WELCOME to the neighborhood. We are happy you came.
Posted by Anonymous on 10/16/2009
does not taste like tin the soprasatta pizza is the bomb
Posted by PHeights on 09/04/2009
I've ordered from here twice and have finally accepted that I should never order from here again. They use canned veggies on their pizza - which turns it into a mushy tin-flavored slop. I couldn't even finish the slice. Not recommended at all if you like fresh and well-made food.