Hold down Control (PC) or Command (Mac) key + mouseclick to select more than one option
Posted by Lorrie Stuart on 2013-09-05
Went to Casallula for the first time last night, and my friends and I were completely delighted. First of all, let's get to the service, which seems to be a bone everyone likes to gnaw on. Our experience was extremely pleasant: when I arrived, the seco
Posted by Columbus Circle Foodie on 2010-10-13
I cannot believe some of these reviews. Who needs huge portions when each bite is enormous in flavor and experience? If you get the grilled cheese/one of the cheese plates, pate, and the chocolate cake to end, you'll think it was the best value in NYC.
Posted by Robert from Hell's kitchen on 2010-06-22
Food is simply spectacular, and they rotate their menu seasonally. Goosebreast ruben open face "sandwich" is enough of a reason to go there everyday. cheese pairings are inspired and sublime. Re: service, it's what one would expect for a small restaurant
Posted by anonymous on 2010-03-24
I normally don't write reviews but felt I needed to after reading the last ones posted here. Three of us spent an evening at Casellula last Friday. When we got there the place was packed, but they managed to seat us within 15 minutes, as promised. The hos
Posted by S. White on 2009-06-22
FOOD: GOOD The food was surprisingly tasty despite the miniscule portions and ridiculous prices. The Pig's Ass sandwich was delicious but I'm shocked the snooty staffers didn't opt to use the sandwich's "proper name" - a Cuban. The Stuffed Peppadew Pe
Posted by dberquist on 2009-06-16
I have been to Casellula several times over the past year, but I will NEVER GO AGAIN after I finally realized that the service is unforgivable. I have always enjoyed the food and wine selections but I can no longer overlook how rude and inconsiderate the
Posted by Anonymous on 2009-06-01
The atmosphere is great, the cheese selection is also great, but the service definitely leaves a bad taste in your mouth. The waitresses had a tone of arrogance about them. If you're willing to overlook that, it's worth a visit.
Posted by pinkstick on 2009-05-20
The cheese selection and the brilliant condiments that compliment tickled me to death. I absolutely adore this place and can't wait to go back !!!