Welcome to MenuPages - Please Select a city:

Casa Pepe (CLOSED)

  • $$$
    RatingAvg. Dinner Entrée
    $$$$$Greater than $25
    $$$$$18.01 - $25
    $$$$12.01 - $18
    $$$7.01 - $12
    $Less than $7
  • Spanish, Mexican
  • 114 Bay Ridge Ave, Brooklyn NY11220 40.6376145 -74.0321368
  • (Btwn Bliss Terrace & Colonial Rd)
  • click map to interact
  • (718) 833-8865
  • 0

User Ratings (Based on 6 reviews)

Food 2.8 Value 2.7
Service 3.2 Atmosphere 3.1

Other Restaurant Info

(718) 833-8865
Visa, MC, AmEx Catering
Mon, Wed-Thu: 12pm-11pm Fri-Sat: 12pm-12am Sun: 12pm-10pm
Lunch, Dinner
Group Dining, Outdoor Dining, Fireplace, Delivery, Wheelchair Friendly, Accepts Credit Cards, Take Out, Catering

User Reviews

  • Casa Pepe

    Posted by johanna on 05/19/2013

    not what I expected

    I went here a couple of months ago thinking that this would be a great experience. The atmosphere was great the service was wonderful. The food not so much. For what they were charging it should have been better. It lacked flavor. Everyone in my group was not happy with what they got. I will not go there again.

  • Casa Pepe

    Posted by Ana on 12/22/2012


    Not very good food and way too pricey.

  • Casa Pepe

    Posted by Anonymous on 11/19/2010

    Great Food

    I don't know where the other reviews are eating, but certainly not Casa Pepe. The food is very good and the service is great. My daughter and I go here every few weeks and have never been disappointed with anything.

  • Casa Pepe

    Posted by Disappointed on 02/22/2010

    Wouldn't Go Back

    We asked for water with out drink order. Had to ask again. My dinner entree was incorrect. I showed the waiter on the menu exactly what I wanted, as well as said it clearly. Screwed that up. Lots of waiters walking around but no one is paying attention. No one listens. The dessert was good and the coffee was great. Other than that, I have no interest in going back.

  • Casa Pepe

    Posted by elaine on 02/11/2010

    very good food

    i was surprised that there was only 1 previous review of this restaurant and that it was so negative. i think casa pepe is an excellent neighborhood restaurant. the food is very good, the service is excellent, and it's a comfortable place. my only negative is that it's a bit pricey for the neighborhood. it's definitely worth trying!

  • Casa Pepe

    Posted by yv204 on 05/18/2009

    Ok Spanish/Mexican family eatery, sort of pricey

    Casa Pepe is one of those restaurants that, plonked down in the middle of Cleveland, would make all local foodie guides. It has everything going for it: a "celebrity" chef, extensive menu that actually lists a number of good Spanish dishes, a viable Mexican roster, paella "family" events, even an enclosed back garden. It's too bad that, in my opinion, this place just doesn't cut it in New York (given I must be in the minority since Casa Pepe has been open a for a goodly long time and does just fine without my regular business). To start with, every single Spanish entree is much more successfully done elsewhere. Mexican dishes are also eclipsed, by Mexican-only places. The dining atmosphere is nice and I keep getting invited to family events at this restaurant, so they must be doing something right, but there is no reason why a middling quantity of guac and nachos should come close to $20. Mind you, none of it tastes exceptional -- chips look supermarket-bought and guacamole, while supposedly prepared table-side (ours wasn't), is so lackluster, I just wanted to smack it upside the head to instill some character into it. Entrees are also blah. Paella tastes like it should have spent less time in the pot (the rice was kinda soggy) and braised short ribs were so inferior to my own good-but-not-THAT-good version, I actually think the restaurant might serve them for a few days running, by just reheating the yesterday's leftovers. By the way, the waiter presented us with a check before we were finished with the last glass of wine and were contemplating ordering dessert. So, I have no opinion of Casa Pepe sweets: for all I know, they might compensate for everything else this restaurant lacks, but I seriously doubt it.

3,000+ menus from the world's most diverse neighborhood.
© 2002-2014 Slick City Media, Inc. All Rights Reserved. MenuPages® is a trademark of Slick City Media, Inc. Disclaimer