Welcome to MenuPages - Please Select a city:


  • $
  • Italian
  • 23 E 74th St, New York 10021 40.773348 -73.964904
  • (Btwn 5th & Madison Ave)
  • click map to interact
  • (212) 288-1004
  • 0

User Ratings (Based on 14 reviews)

avg-come back to15
Food 3_5 Value 2_5
Service 3_5 Atmosphere 4

Other Restaurant Info

(212) 288-1004
Visa, MC, AmEx
Mon-Fri: 12pm-11pm Sun: 12pm-10pm
Accepts Credit Cards, Lunch, Lunch Special, Online Reservations, Private Parties, Prix Fix Menus, Wheelchair Accessible

User Reviews

  • Caravaggio

    Posted by Griffin on 2015-01-05

    So full of Themselves

    This was one of the most uncomfortable dining experiences of my life! The waiter was rude and obnoxious. He insisted my husband sit facing the door instead of facing me. He said "Most people sit facing the door, why would you sit facing that way." Pay

  • Caravaggio

    Posted by Lisa on 2014-04-28

    Skip It

    I've been to this restaurant twice; once on business and once personally, (this past Friday night). Perhaps there aren't many restaurants that are prettier, as sophisticated in design or as relaxing but unfortunately that's where it begins and ends, as b

  • Caravaggio

    Posted by Anonymous on 2014-02-24


    Having just arrived from Milano , my concierge suggested this restaurant , and it was a great choice.the mare appetizer was full of shrimp , scallops, and lobster.the risotto , a dish I make and have 4 -5 times a week, was creamy and cooked to perfection.

  • Caravaggio

    Posted by milari hare www.livealittlenow.com on 2013-03-18

    Amazing Truffles!!

    One of my favorite haunts! I am from Seattle but in the city every other month and have been coming since the Cocco Pazzo days. I enjoyed the most fabulous dish of black truffles more than generously shaved over house made pasta. The appetizer portion was

  • Caravaggio

    Posted by Gina on 2012-11-30

    avoid the shell fish!

    The atmosphere at Caravaggio is lovely, but ugh, the food was not good and the service clumsy (and quite intrusive, often interrupting conversation). I ordered the lobster and artichoke ravioli and couldn't eat much of it because its fishy-ness was overw

  • Caravaggio

    Posted by michelle on 2012-09-18

    skip it

    we also picked this restaurant based on open table. They called to confirm the reservation twice the day of our meal and still couldn't find us in the computer system when our party of 5 arrived on time. The service was generally poor - for example, our g

  • Caravaggio

    Posted by Joanne on 2012-09-11

    Not Recommended

    Please save yourself from the experience that you will have at Caravaggio. My husband found this restaurant on open table in the top 10 Italian restaurants in NYC. Not true! First off the waiter had no clue what beers were on the menu or if he actually

  • Caravaggio

    Posted by LIC Foodie on 2012-02-06

    Very Underwhelmed

    My wife and I read all these amazing reviews about Caravaggio so we had pretty high expectations. First, I'll say the room/atmosphere is great and the service was top notch as well. Having said that, the food was honestly average, at best. My wife

© 2018 Grubhub, Inc. All rights reserved.