Welcome to MenuPages - Please Select a city:

Caffe Storico

at the New York Historical Society
  • RatingAvg. Dinner Entrée
    $$$$$Greater than $25
    $$$$$18.01 - $25
    $$$$12.01 - $18
    $$$7.01 - $12
    $Less than $7
  • Italian
  • 170 Central Park W, New York NY10024 40.77924 -73.97441
  • (Btwn 76th & 77th St)
  • click map to interact
  • (212) 485-9211
  • 0

User Ratings (Based on 8 reviews)

Food 4.1 Value 2.9
Service 4.2 Atmosphere 3.3

Other Restaurant Info

(212) 485-9211
Visa, MC, AmEx, Disc
Tue-Sun: 11am-10pm
Brunch, Dinner
Accepts Credit Cards, Catering, Lunch, Online Reservations, Private Parties, Prix Fix Menus, Wheelchair Accessible

User Reviews

  • Caffe Storico

    Posted by Archy feet on 12/29/2014

    Not recommended

    Took two friends visiting from out of town here for sunday brunch after christmas, hoping it would bring them some down time to relax. But the place is noisy. I felt odd that the waitresses kept asking us if we wanted side items or appetizers. I understod why when i saw the smal portion. But good thing it is small because My pappardelle is soggy and soupy. I felt so embarassed taking people here.

  • Caffe Storico

    Posted by Anonymous on 08/01/2014

    About a C+

    Portions are small--and they really lied about the "lump crab meat". It was tiny pieces, probably from the claws, and amounted only to a very small garnish to the pasta. The other dish we had, also a pasta, was small also. And these were both from the regular menu, not the Restaurant Week menu. Don't really expect a meal--just a small snack. Quite expensive for that.

  • Caffe Storico

    Posted by carol on 12/26/2012

    Good place to eat when at the museum

    This restaurant is just way too noisy. The food is very good, and not overpriced for Manhattan, but the servers are quite blase. And even though I am a volunteer at the museum and get a 20% discount for the cafe, they are never able to remember this, meaning I have to ask several times, which is embarassing. All in all, I think the convenience outweighs the drawbacks, but it's not the great experience it claims to be.

  • Caffe Storico

    Posted by Francobollo on 02/13/2012

    Almost perfect.

    I really wanted to love this place and I almost did. The food is delicious from the bread basket to the desserts. The room is beautiful but it lacks any real warmth. It's all done in white and yellow (lovely) but there is a wood floor and marble topped tables. The chairs are also metal and it gives the whole place a bit of a corporate cafeteria feel. Also, because of all these hard surfaces, the place is incredibly noisy. There was one boisterous table the night I dined there and my friends and I could not hear each other. The simplest quick fix would be to put white tablecloths on the tables in the evening. This would buffer the noise a bit and make the restaurant seem a bit more elegant for an evening out. Let's hope Stephen Starr sees the review and takes the hint!

  • Caffe Storico

    Posted by Anonymous on 01/30/2012

    kids size portions

    The place is lovely and the service was great. However, we left still hungry. I went with 3 friends and we had the rigatoni and the risotto. All were excellent, but the portions were small, more like kids portions. I asked for an extra bread basket because we were all still starving after dinner.

  • Caffe Storico

    Posted by Anonymous on 01/13/2012

    Beautiful and delicious

    This is a great spot. Whether you are going to the museum or just going to Caffe Storico. I had lunch and dinner here and both meals were amazing. The restaurant is so pretty, the service is great and the food wonderful. The menu is inventive. I recommend this for any occassion. They just need to dim the lights a bit for dinner.

  • Caffe Storico

    Posted by anonymous on 12/28/2011

    What's better than history AND great dining?

    If your idea of a great day in NYC involves history - and great food - you must visit Caffe Storico. Our first trip to the impressively restored NY Historical Society ended with a delightful dining experience. Although it was a rainy, dreary night in NYC, the high ceilings, white walls, mirrors, and the society's china collections created a cheerful, warm, uncluttered atmosphere. (I can only imagine how lovely it must be during a sunny day.) The light atmosphere of the setting reflected the superbly delicate but satisfying Italian dishes. Knowledgable staff guided us through our course selections, each of which was excellent. Coupled with great wines (also at the suggestion of staff) we left dutifully impressed. Do try as many of the pasta dishes as you can, you won't be disappointed.

© 2015 GrubHub, Inc. All rights reserved.