Welcome to MenuPages - Please Select a city:

Cielo at the Mayfair (Formerly Caffe Cielo)

  • $$$
    RatingAvg. Dinner Entrée
    $$$$$Greater than $25
    $$$$$18.01 - $25
    $$$$12.01 - $18
    $$$7.01 - $12
    $Less than $7
  • Italian
  • 242 W 49th St, New York NY10019 40.76138 -73.9859319
  • (Btwn Broadway & 8th Ave)
  • click map to interact
  • (212) 489-8600
  • 0

User Ratings (Based on 34 reviews)

Food 4.2 Value 4.1
Service 4.2 Atmosphere 4.1

Other Restaurant Info

(212) 489-8600
(212) 265-6118
Place Order:
Order From Cielo at the Mayfair (Formerly Caffe Cielo) for delivery & takeout
Visa, MC, AmEx, Disc
Mon-Fri: 12pm-12am Sat-Sun: 11am-12am
Lunch, Dinner
Pre/Post Theater, Live Entertainment, Gluten Free Items, Online Ordering, Wheelchair Friendly, Accepts Credit Cards, Take Out

User Reviews

  • Cielo at the Mayfair (Formerly Caffe Cielo)

    Posted by Mike V on 06/27/2014

    Food is traditional Italian and best in Times Square

    The food and service is excellent and hard to compare against any other venue in the neighborhood.

  • Cielo at the Mayfair (Formerly Caffe Cielo)

    Posted by Tucker F on 05/23/2013

    Delightful and delicious

    Home-made pasta, delicious sauces, good service, friendly all around: I will return. I recommend this charming place and I will be returning. See you there!

  • Cielo at the Mayfair (Formerly Caffe Cielo)

    Posted by EPR on 04/19/2012

    Nice Average Italian Restaurant

    My friend and I had dinner at this place before heading to the theater and we had no complaint. Food was good, service and ambience were ok. It's not a top restaurant but not bad either.

  • Cielo at the Mayfair (Formerly Caffe Cielo)

    Posted by Hawkeye on 04/05/2012

    Mediocre at best

    Took our son and his wife based on recommendations here and were very disappointed. Service was indifferent and food was very generic. Won't be going back.

  • Cielo at the Mayfair (Formerly Caffe Cielo)

    Posted by Buddy on 12/24/2011

    Frequent diners

    My wife and I live in the neighborhood and often dine here. We have always been extemely pleased with the food and the service. The fried calamari is among the "best in town" and the other fish entrees have never disappointed, especially the sole.

  • Cielo at the Mayfair (Formerly Caffe Cielo)

    Posted by hot lips on 11/01/2009

    agitating experience

    Chose restaurant based on on line reviews and proximity to theater I was going to. I eat out very very often but was disappointed from the beginning of the meal when the bread arrived. This is an Italian restaurant in New York City with many many bakeries. They serve white bread which was terrible! Any plain Italian bread would have been better. Once the waitress took our order, we never saw her again. The prices are a little high for what you are getting. I ordered a salad which was $12.50. Icould have been sitting in a far better and nicer looking restaurant or that price. When my pasta dish arrived it had very very little sauce. The waitress was no where to be found. The person giving out the bread and water finally came over and he was the one to bring out more sauce. Overall the food is o.k., but there are always other restaurants to choose from.

  • Cielo at the Mayfair (Formerly Caffe Cielo)

    Posted by MR. ANDERSON on 04/27/2009

    Excellent Dining Experience

    I often use the reviews from previous patrons as part of my selection process, and it really paid off this time. “What a great group of people at this Restaurant”. Making reservations was painless and they graciously thanked us ahead of time. Heavy traffic caused us to be late by over a ½ hour late, but we called ahead and they told us to still come whenever we got into NYC. Upon arrival we didn’t have enough time to eat Dinner before our show, but they gladly accommodated us at the Bar where we enjoyed a drink and nice appetizer. Told them we would return later for Dinner. Upon returning we were greeted by name and once again provided excellent service again. Oh I forgot; the Food and Décor were great too. A very pleasant experience; will become a regular spot for us!

3,000+ menus from the world's most diverse neighborhood.
© 2002-2014 Slick City Media, Inc. All Rights Reserved. MenuPages® is a trademark of Slick City Media, Inc. Disclaimer