Welcome to MenuPages - Please Select a city:

Cafe Fiorello

  • RatingAvg. Dinner Entrée
    $$$$$Greater than $25
    $$$$$18.01 - $25
    $$$$12.01 - $18
    $$$7.01 - $12
    $Less than $7
  • Italian, Pizza, Steakhouses
  • 1900 Broadway, New York NY10023 40.771373 -73.982035
  • (Btwn 63rd & 64th St)
  • click map to interact
  • (212) 595-5330
  • 0

User Ratings (Based on 78 reviews)

Food 3.7 Value 2.8
Service 3.4 Atmosphere 3.5

Other Restaurant Info

(212) 595-5330
Visa, MC, AmEx, Disc, DC, JCB
Lunch Mon-Fri: 11:30am-4pm Dinner Mon-Fri: 4pm-12:30am Sat: 3pm-12:30am Sun: 3pm-11pm Brunch Sat-Sun: 10am-3pm
Brunch, Dinner, Lunch
Accepts Credit Cards, Business Dining, Delivery, Good for Groups, Lunch Special, Online Reservations, Outdoor Seating, People Watching, Pre/Post Theater, Private Parties, Prix Fix Menus, Take Out, Wheelchair Accessible
Min Delivery:
Delivery Area:
59th to 72nd St; Central Park W to W End Ave

User Reviews

  • Cafe Fiorello

    Posted by ilikefood on 03/06/2009

    Spare me the attitude

    It was practically empty when a group of eight of us went there post-opera. Even though waitstaff lounged around nearby, hand waving didn't bring anyone over. After 20 minutes, I went to the bar and asked for a waiter. Same thing happened when we wanted the check. The food and wine tasted fine, but the price was at least 1/3 more than a pizza and a glass of mediocre montepulciano ought to cost, even near Lincoln Center.

  • Cafe Fiorello

    Posted by anava104 on 02/08/2009

    way too expensive

    Way too much money for what you get. I've had the same quality of food at other places for 1/2 the price. I only saw 1 chicken entree on the menu. Even the pizza's are close to $30 per pie. CRAZY!! So not worth it! I live in Astoria where the restaurants are so much better and the portions more substantial. I understand it's Manhattan but I have eaten in the city so many times and have been impressed with other restaurants. Don't go. And if you do, expect to pay your left arm and right leg!!

  • Cafe Fiorello

    Posted by Steve on 01/18/2009

    Tourist trap

    Average food and expensive for what you get. There is much better in the neighborhood.

  • Cafe Fiorello

    Posted by take on 10/25/2008

    wait wait wait

    Sat at the bar Saturday evening. We waited 1 hour 10 minutes for our entrees. Food was awful. Pizza greasy and baby artichokes were full-grown and fibrous. Service was non existent. This place used to be one of our favorite neighbohood spots where we would always be remembered and welcomed. Now, they change the menu every couple of months, like they do with every one of Shelley Firemen's restaurants, They've lost all of their good hosts and waiters and the place is way overpriced for what you get. We're not returning.

  • Cafe Fiorello

    Posted by Anonymous on 09/06/2008

    So Not Worth The Money or Time

    I can't figure out what was worse - the food, the service or the prices. The veal was like cardboard, the asparagus was chewy and oily and the soup was greasy. This used to be a very nice restaurant but no longer. It took forever to get the food, service was chaotic, when we asked the hostess if she could please see where our order was, we were basically ignored. I would not recommend this place.

  • Cafe Fiorello

    Posted by Cuso on 07/13/2008

    Ugggghh (minus the open faced Lasagna)

    We had a 5:30 reservation for 4, arrived and seated on time, and that was about the only good thing besides the lasagna. We ordered one antipasto appetizer at 6:00 and our entree's at the same time. We FINALLY got our food at 7:30 and we had an 8pm show, that we were just able to make. The waiter never once apologized for the long wait time for the food, and kept making empty promises on when we would get our food. The food was good, but not great and not worth how expensive it was. It was extremely stuffy, and the seating was too close for comfort, we were on top of the tables to our right and left. No thanks...

  • Cafe Fiorello

    Posted by westsidenewlywed on 06/29/2008

    Crowded and ridiculously expensive

    My husband and I dined at Fiorello last Friday night. We had a 6pm reservation and when we arrived, the place was packedunusual at that hour for New York. It was absolutely a pre-theater crowdwe're in our late 20s and we were the youngest people there by an average of 20 years. It felt strangely like a Carmine's or other Times Square tourist hangoutthe priority was turning over the tables, and once she took our order, our waitress disappeared until we stopped her to ask for the check. It is extremely crowdedso much so that squeezing between our table and the next to use the ladies' room got me uncomfortably close to our neighbors. The food was so-soI LOVED my open-faced lasagna but my husband wasn't crazy about his pizza. It was the thinnest-crust pizza I've ever seen, so not everyone's style. The food is also very expensivethe appetizer/antipasto bar sounds intriguing but for $18 I got 3 spears of asparagus, a tiny slice of quiche, and two slices of roasted peppers. Outrageous! Even the simple pasta dishes were in the $20s....So, I'm glad we went to cross it off our list but I doubt we'll be back.

© 2015 GrubHub, Inc. All rights reserved.