Welcome to MenuPages - Please Select a city:

Cafe Fiorello

  • RatingAvg. Dinner Entrée
    $$$$$Greater than $25
    $$$$$18.01 - $25
    $$$$12.01 - $18
    $$$7.01 - $12
    $Less than $7
  • Italian, Pizza, Steakhouses
  • 1900 Broadway, New York NY10023 40.771373 -73.982035
  • (Btwn 63rd & 64th St)
  • click map to interact
  • (212) 595-5330
  • 0

User Ratings (Based on 78 reviews)

Food 3.7 Value 2.8
Service 3.4 Atmosphere 3.5

Other Restaurant Info

(212) 595-5330
Visa, MC, AmEx, Disc, DC, JCB
Lunch Mon-Fri: 11:30am-4pm Dinner Mon-Fri: 4pm-12:30am Sat: 3pm-12:30am Sun: 3pm-11pm Brunch Sat-Sun: 10am-3pm
Brunch, Dinner, Lunch
Accepts Credit Cards, Business Dining, Delivery, Good for Groups, Lunch Special, Online Reservations, Outdoor Seating, People Watching, Pre/Post Theater, Private Parties, Prix Fix Menus, Take Out, Wheelchair Accessible
Min Delivery:
Delivery Area:
59th to 72nd St; Central Park W to W End Ave

User Reviews

  • Cafe Fiorello

    Posted by letseat on 06/19/2012

    What happened to this place?

    We used to come here all the time but were away for a year and now the food has changed so much! The breadbasket is disappointing - I loved the crispy parmesan bread and the fluffy focaccia, the former is now stale and the latter oily and blah. The list of appetizers has shrunk and nothing interesting is left. The chicken liver in balsamic used to be my favorite and it is gone. The pizza crust has unfortunately changed too. So the only good thing left are the desserts - the best cannoli in town!

  • Cafe Fiorello

    Posted by Elaine on 03/16/2012

    An Excellent Experience

    I recently had dinner at Fiorello's before a performance at Lincoln Center. The antipasto bar was a great way to expedite your meal and all of the offerings were delicious. I was particularly impressed with the service however. The barman, Trevor, who I believe has been there for years, is a true expert at his craft and sitting at his bar, I felt as comfortable as if I was in my own living room. Michael, the guy in charge, was gracious, attentive, and you could tell he really knew what he was doing. All in all, for a place that does a ton of volume and in a short span of time, they really had the personal touch. I would definitely go back, and recommend it to all my friends and colleagues. You really can see why it is such an institution, and it is nice to see that they don't take their great reputation for granted.

  • Cafe Fiorello

    Posted by Mary H on 02/26/2012

    Crowded but good

    I really liked this place, apart from how crammed in we all were. It was valentine's night and I felt as though I was enjoying a date with not only my husband, but the bald guy to my right and the lady to my left! The food however, was very good and the service too - very attentive table service. Would definitely go again, but perhaps not for a romantic night out!

  • Cafe Fiorello

    Posted by Sean on 02/18/2012

    Very pleased

    I've eaten at Cafe Fiorello at least three times in the last 6 months and have not been disappointed even once with either the service or the meal. Yes, perhaps it's a bit pretentious. I've had their special lasagna and it is beautiful to behold and magnificent to taste. For those concerned about portion size, this is the meal to order! I'm happy to say that they've added the deliciously spicy meatballs on the lasagna to their bucatoni americiana and in doing so they have added an exciting taste sensation to an already quality Italian specialty. No, the bowl does not overflow with pasta but there is certainly enough for a hearty meal. The appetizer of scallops and shrimp is a very special treat I reserve for special ocassions. The staff is fantastically kind, helpful and efficient. I left my credit card behind one night and the woman who helped me on the phone when I called could not have been more gracious. Anything I dislike? I don't like the choice of breads they serve. I've never had room for dessert.

  • Cafe Fiorello

    Posted by val on 12/17/2011

    location location location

    I expected high prices but this was a farce. The food portions were half of what you would expect. I ordered a salad with shaved parm. There were a few scraps of parm over a handful of romaine. The lasagna was open face like a taco. They took the fastest cheapest way out. $30 for that pasta taco by the way. The service was easily ticked off, I felt like a burden. I suppose because they are in a great location they think it's okay to serve slop with an attitude.

  • Cafe Fiorello

    Posted by Local eater on 11/20/2011

    Massively overpriced

    Pizza was ok and unique but the pizza was more than twice other pizza's in town. and its not that great, but ok.

  • Cafe Fiorello

    Posted by Upper Westsider on 10/17/2011

    I Love this Place

    This is the place I take all my out of town guests as well as neighbors. I have never been disappointed. I love to sit at the bar as all the bar tenders remember names, faces, and couldn't be more gracious. The antipasti bar is always a treat to the eye and the palate, as well as being a good value. Everyone that I send there, loves there experience!This has been my favorite westside restaurant"hangout" for a very longtime.

© 2015 GrubHub, Inc. All rights reserved.