
Hold down Control (PC) or Command (Mac) key + mouseclick to select more than one option
| Rating | Avg. Dinner Entrée |
|---|---|
| $$$$$ | Greater than $25 |
| $$$$ | $18.01 - $25 |
| $$$ | $12.01 - $18 |
| $$ | $7.01 - $12 |
| $ | Less than $7 |
Reviews + Photos from nymag.com
| Food | ![]() |
Value | ![]() |
|---|---|---|---|
| Service | ![]() |
Atmosphere | ![]() |
Posted by val on 12/17/2011
location location location
I expected high prices but this was a farce. The food portions were half of what you would expect. I ordered a salad with shaved parm. There were a few scraps of parm over a handful of romaine. The lasagna was open face like a taco. They took the fastest cheapest way out. $30 for that pasta taco by the way. The service was easily ticked off, I felt like a burden. I suppose because they are in a great location they think it's okay to serve slop with an attitude.
Posted by Local eater on 11/20/2011
Massively overpriced
Pizza was ok and unique but the pizza was more than twice other pizza's in town. and its not that great, but ok.
Posted by Upper Westsider on 10/17/2011
I Love this Place
This is the place I take all my out of town guests as well as neighbors. I have never been disappointed. I love to sit at the bar as all the bar tenders remember names, faces, and couldn't be more gracious. The antipasti bar is always a treat to the eye and the palate, as well as being a good value. Everyone that I send there, loves there experience!This has been my favorite westside restaurant"hangout" for a very longtime.
Posted by LindaSolo on 08/29/2011
Overpriced Main courses more like appetizers
A dear friend loves this place. I neverwant to go there again. It is very overpriced for what they serve you. As an example the last tie I was there I had a pasta dish that waslisted on the menu as having pieces pf Italian sausage in it. I was hard pressed to find any sauge past the 2 or 3 small pieces that were more liek crumbled pieces of sausage. And while the flavor was good(not brillant) the portion of pasta was very small, more like an appetizer portion. And the price was $22.00.I wouldn't have minded that much if perhaps a small salad (and believe me, knowing this place, it would have been small)had accompanied it. We had to ask for the the bread and olive oil that usually comes automatically here. And we did not get served our drinks until we had finished our meal,even thoug we reminded the waitress 3 times. Another time I was there the waiter we had was very inattentive and we had to ask him several times for things as well. On both ocassions it was not as if they were extremely busy...we were there on off hours. Sufice to say I will never patronize this establishment again. The food has a nice flavor, but hte portions are quite small and ovepriced and while the waitstaff is pleasant most of them are very young and seem not to have great attention spans when it comes to servicing their patrons.
Posted by Sus on 07/31/2011
way overpriced!
I thought the food was great here, as was the service. But wow...$220 dollars for two of us to have a pretty regular dinner...salad, lasagna, low-end bottle of wine. I live in the city, and am used to high prices, but this place seemed like the most expensive place I've ever eaten (for what it was).
Posted by Eileen B on 06/23/2011
Four disappointed diners
This was a huge disappointment. There were four of us, and we found that the lasagne was subpar, the pasta barely adequate, the lemon sole so spiced it was unrecognizable, and the Marguerita pizza was cold. It was so noisy that conversation was difficult, and tables were virtually on top of each other. The only plus was excellent service, but I'd never go there again.
Posted by anonymous on 05/11/2011
So overpriced
I lived in this neighborhood for almost 6 years and was really looking forward to trying cafe fiorello as I past it almost everyday. I cant begin to tell you what a let down it was. 2 appetizers, 2 beers and 1 Pasta dish was $100. The Pasta Carbonara was 3 long noodles and one slice of Pancetta. Best thing about the place was that I was sitting across from my best friend talking about how we got dooped! We had to snack when we got home because the portions were so small.